Behaviour as Communication

3.1 The main points

Behaviour is a message. The useful question is not why the child did it, but what they need. “Will not” and “cannot” look the same from the outside and need completely different responses. Shame sits underneath most of the behaviour carers find hardest. Our children often cannot say sorry. Pushing for an apology makes things worse. Lower the shame and the behaviour usually settles. If something is happening right now, look it up in Common Challenges: An A–Z.

3.2 Reading the behaviour

3.2.1 The question to ask

When a child does something difficult, the question most adults ask is “why did you do that?” It almost never works. The child usually does not know. If they were frightened at the time, the thinking part of their brain was not in charge, and there is no answer to give you. So they say “I don’t know”, or they make something up, or they say nothing, and the adult thinks they are being difficult. Two better questions, asked in your own head rather than out loud: What is this child afraid of? What do they need right now? You will often be wrong. That is fine. Asking the question changes what you do next, and that is the point.

3.2.2 “Will not” and “cannot”

From the outside, a child who will not do something and a child who cannot do something look exactly the same. Both are standing there not doing it. But they need opposite responses. A child who will not needs a boundary. A child who cannot needs help. A child who cannot get in the shower is not being defiant. They may be frightened of the bathroom. They may not be able to make themselves start a task. They may be somewhere else in their head entirely. When you are not sure which one you are looking at, assume “cannot” first. If you offer help and the child did not need it, you have lost nothing. If you give a consequence to a child who could not do it, you have taught them that trying and failing gets punished.

3.2.3 What the behaviour might be telling you

Some everyday examples. None of these are rules, because the same behaviour means different things in different children. They are examples of the kind of thinking we want. A child takes food and hides it in their room. They are not stealing from you. Food ran out once, or was used as a punishment, or nobody made any. The child is making sure. Arguing about it will not help. Making food freely available, permanently and without comment, usually does. A child lies about something you watched them do. This looks like it must be deliberate, and it rarely is in the way adults assume. For a child who has been punished harshly, admitting something is dangerous. The lie is a reflex, not a plan. Pressing for a confession turns a small thing into an hour. A child refuses to get out of the car. Something about where you have arrived is frightening, or they are not ready to stop being somewhere safe. The transition itself is the problem, not the destination. A child destroys a present you have just given them. This one hurts. A present can be unbearable for a child who does not believe they deserve good things, or who is waiting for the catch. Breaking it ends the discomfort.

3.2.4 Blocked trust

Some children get worse when things get better. Carers find this bewildering, and it is one of the most common reasons placements come under strain. The reason is that kindness can be frightening. If being cared for has always come with a price, or has always been followed by loss, then a warm, safe home is not reassuring. It is a warning sign. So as a child begins to settle, they may start testing. They are finding out what you do when they are at their worst, because that is the only information that counts. This is called blocked trust. It is a sign you are getting somewhere, although it does not feel like it. The answer is to keep being the same.

Critical Actions — 9. Analysis

Reading the behaviour is the analysis step. Noticing that a child is distressed is observation. Working out what the distress is for, and what would meet it, is the part that changes anything.

3.3 Shame

3.3.1 What shame is

There is a difference between guilt and shame, and it matters. Guilt is I did something bad. It is uncomfortable, and it is useful. It is what makes a person put something right. Shame is I am bad. It is not about the thing that happened. It is about the whole person. It is unbearable, and nobody can sit in it for long. A child who feels guilty can apologise and move on. A child who feels shame has to escape it, and escaping it is what you see.

3.3.2 Why our children carry so much of it

Children work out very early that they are the centre of everything that happens around them. If something goes wrong, they assume it is about them. So a child who was neglected does not conclude that their parent was unwell. They conclude that they were not worth feeding. A child who was hit does not conclude that the adult had no control. They conclude that they are the kind of child people hit. A child who was taken into care does not conclude that the adults could not keep them safe. They conclude that they were too much. None of this is reasoned out, and none of it can be argued away. Telling a child it was not their fault does not reach it. It is a feeling about who they are, laid down before they had words.

3.3.3 What shame looks like from the outside

Shame almost never looks like shame. It looks like: Rage that seems far too big for what happened Laughing or smirking at the worst possible moment Blaming somebody else, loudly and obviously Flat denial of something you watched them do Going blank, or going silent, or leaving the room Saying “I don’t care”, or “I’m rubbish anyway”, or “just put me somewhere else then” All of these are ways of getting out from under an unbearable feeling. The child is not managing the situation. They are managing the feeling.

3.3.4 The shame spiral

The pattern usually runs like this. The child does something. An adult responds, perfectly reasonably. The response lands as you are bad. The child cannot bear it, so they do something worse: they shout, they deny, they walk out, they break something. The adult now responds to the worse thing. The shame goes up again. And round it goes, until somebody stops. Nothing in that spiral is about the original thing. Within about thirty seconds the argument is no longer about the broken cup. It is about whether this child is a bad person, and they are losing. You cannot win a shame spiral. You can only step out of it.

3.4 Why the usual responses make shame worse

Four things adults do, all reasonable, all of which make things worse. Asking for an apology. Saying sorry means admitting you did a bad thing. For a child who already feels like a bad person, that is not a small ask. Pushing for an apology turns a two-minute problem into an hour, and often into a bigger incident. Let it go for now. Repair can happen without the word. “Look at me when I am talking to you.” Eye contact is how shame gets in. A child who is already overwhelmed cannot hold your gaze, and forcing it is experienced as an attack. Let them look away. They can still hear you. Asking them to explain themselves. “What were you thinking?” has no answer. The child was not thinking. Being asked to explain something they cannot explain adds humiliation to the feeling they already have. Correcting them in front of other people. In front of their brothers and sisters, their friends, your friends, the whole family at the table. Whatever the words, the message a shame-prone child receives is: everyone can see what I am. If you need to say something, say it later and privately.

Critical Actions — 5. Interventions completed

Apologies demanded, eye contact insisted on, consequences explained at length: these have usually been tried many times, by many adults, before the child reached you. Ask what has already been done to this child in the name of correction, and assume shame is the reason it did not work.

3.5 Lowering the shame

The aim is not to let things go. It is to get the shame low enough that the child can hear you, which is the only state in which anything gets learned. Name the need, not the behaviour. “You were really hungry” rather than “you stole food again”. “That was too much all at once” rather than “you completely overreacted”. You are telling the child you understand, which is the opposite of telling them what they are. Get alongside rather than opposite. Standing face to face and looking down at a child makes it feel like a telling-off before you have said anything. Sit next to them. Walk. Talk in the car, where nobody has to look at anybody. Difficult conversations go better side by side. Keep your face and voice warm while you hold the line. The boundary can stay exactly where it is. It is your face that tells the child whether they are still all right with you. You can say no warmly. Most adults say no coldly without noticing. Come back later. When everyone is calm, return to it briefly. “That was a rough one earlier. I’ve been thinking about it.” Keep it short. The point is that you came back, not what you say. Let them save face. Give the child a way out that does not require them to admit anything. Offer a job, change the subject, suggest a drink, leave the room so they can come out of their corner without an audience. Winning is not the aim.

Critical Actions — 12. Interventions to implement

Choose the next approach for the shame it avoids, not the behaviour it targets. Agree with your supervising social worker what you are trying, for how long, and what would show you it is working.

3.6 Naming feelings, and children who cannot

3.6.1 Children who cannot say what they feel

Some children genuinely cannot tell you what they are feeling. Not will not. Cannot. They may have three words for everything: fine, bored, angry. They may say they do not know and be telling the truth. They may describe a feeling as a physical thing, which is accurate: a tummy ache, feeling sick, being tired. They may not be able to tell angry from frightened, or hungry from sad, or excited from anxious, because from the inside those feel very similar. This is a missing skill rather than a refusal. Naming feelings is taught, usually by an adult who notices a child’s state and gives it a word, thousands of times across early childhood. A child who had nobody doing that arrives without the vocabulary. So “how do you feel?” and “why did you do that?” get you nothing, and go on getting you nothing, because the child does not have the answer in a form they can hand over.

3.6.2 Teaching the words

Name it for them, as a guess. “I think you might be fed up.” “That looked like it frightened you.” Say it lightly and do not require agreement. Over time the child takes the words. Name your own out loud. “I’m getting frustrated with this, I’m going to leave it for ten minutes.” This is the most effective method there is, because it shows the child the whole sequence: a feeling, a word for it, and something sensible done about it. Use other people and characters. What the person in the programme is feeling. What the dog is feeling. Why the character in the book did that. A child who will not discuss their own feelings will often discuss somebody else’s at length, and it is the same learning. Separate the feeling from the size of it. Annoyed, cross, furious. Worried, frightened, terrified. Many of our children have only the top of the scale, because only the top of the scale ever got a response. Use the body. Where do you feel it? What does it feel like? Children can often locate a feeling before they can name it, and that is a real answer rather than a failure to answer. Accept “I don’t know” and move on. Do not press. “That’s all right. Tell me if you work it out.”

3.6.3 Reading other people

Some children are poor at reading faces and tone. Some read them extremely well and assume the worst. The first group misses the signal altogether. The second group has been trained on danger, so a neutral face reads as anger and a quiet adult reads as about to erupt. Both end up reacting to something that is not happening. What helps is saying out loud what your own face is doing, particularly when it is nothing to do with them. “I’m frowning because I’m reading something annoying. It isn’t you.” Staying Calm covers the rest of this. For a child who misreads other children, do it in the moment and lightly. “I don’t think he was having a go. I think he just wanted a turn.”

3.6.4 Joining the feeling to the behaviour

The point of all of it is the link. Not only that a child can name a feeling, but that they can eventually see what the feeling made them do. Do that afterwards, never during, and tell it as a story rather than asking it as a question. “I think what happened was that you were starving by the time we got in, and then the thing with the shoes happened, and it all went up from there.” Say it once. Do not ask them to confirm it. Do not add what they should have done instead. Over months, a child who has had their own sequence narrated back to them enough times starts to narrate it themselves, and that is where it begins to change what they do. It is slow, and it is the actual work.

3.7 When a child cannot do the work

3.7.1 Being behind, and knowing it

A great many of our children are behind at school, often by years. Missed schooling, changing schools, being unable to concentrate in a classroom while frightened, an unassessed need, or a brain that developed in conditions which did not allow learning. A child who is behind knows it. They sit next to children who can do it. They get asked to read aloud. They can see which group they are in. And they draw the obvious conclusion, which is not “I have missed a lot of school” but “I am stupid”. That belief is one of the most damaging things a child can carry out of care, and it drives a large amount of school refusal, classroom behaviour and refusing to try.

3.7.2 What it looks like

Behaviour that gets the child out of the room before the work starts. Being funny, being rude, needing the toilet, a sudden argument, a broken pencil, refusing to take their coat off. Destroying their own work, or saying it is rubbish before anybody else can. Refusing to try anything new at all, at school or at home, including things they would enjoy. Claiming not to care. “School’s pointless.” “I’m not doing it.” Almost always protection. Very large distress over a small mistake. Never asking for help, because asking announces that you cannot do it.

3.7.3 What helps

Take the shame out of it before you take the gap out of it. No child learns while humiliated, and everything else here depends on this. Say the true explanation out loud, more than once. “You missed a lot of school. That’s why this is hard. It isn’t because of anything about you.” A child who has an explanation that is not about their worth can start trying again. Separate being behind from being stupid, explicitly. Children do not make that distinction on their own, and nobody usually makes it for them. Never let homework become the battle. If homework is wrecking your evenings and your relationship with the child, stop, tell the school you have stopped, and say why. The relationship matters more than the homework does. Work at the level they are actually at. Reading something easy that they can read builds more than struggling through the book for their age. Push for the assessment. Learning delay, speech and language, dyslexia, hearing, sight, or a wider need. Ask in writing, ask for it in the child’s personal education plan, and ask at the review. Children in care wait longer for this than they should, and a carer asking repeatedly is often what moves it. Get them good at something that is not schoolwork. Belonging, Confidence And Friendships covers why that matters so much. For a child who fails all day, the thing they are good at in the evening is what keeps them intact. Tell the school what you have noticed and ask what support is in place. Speaking up for a child covers how to put it so that it lands, and we will help you push for it.