Behaviour as communication
Good practice guidance
This page is good practice guidance. It is not policy and it does not set out a statutory requirement. It is here to support the learning and practice of everyone at Sparks Fostering.
A child’s behaviour tells you something about what they need. This page covers how to read behaviour, why shame sits underneath so much of what carers find hardest, and how to respond in a way that lowers shame so the child can hear you.
The main points
- Behaviour is a message. Ask yourself what the child needs before you ask why they did it.
- A child who will not do something and a child who cannot do it look the same and need opposite responses.
- Shame sits underneath most of the behaviour carers find hardest.
- The children we look after often can’t say sorry, and pushing for an apology makes things worse.
- When the shame is lower, the behaviour usually settles.
- If something is happening right now, look it up in Common challenges: an A–Z.
Reading the behaviour
The question to ask.
“Why did you do that?” almost never works, because the child usually doesn’t know.
Ask yourself two questions, in your head: what is this child afraid of, and what do they need right now? You will often be wrong, but asking changes what you do next.
“Will not” and “cannot”.
A child who will not do something needs a boundary. A child who cannot do it needs help. From the outside they look the same.
When you are not sure, assume “cannot” first. Offering help that was not needed costs nothing.
What the behaviour might be telling you.
- A child hides food in their room. Food ran out once, or was used as a punishment. Make food freely available, without comment.
- A child lies about something you watched them do. For a child who has been punished harshly the lie is a reflex. Don’t press for a confession.
- A child refuses to get out of the car. Something about where you have arrived is frightening, or they are not ready to leave somewhere that feels safe.
- A child destroys a present. A child who does not believe they deserve good things can find a present very uncomfortable.
Blocked trust.
Some children get worse as things get better. As they begin to settle they test you, to find out what you do when they are at their worst. It usually means the child is starting to trust you. Carry on being the same.
Shame
What shame is.
Guilt is the feeling that you did something bad, and it makes a person want to put things right. Shame is the feeling that you are bad. A child who feels shame has to get away from the feeling, and that is the behaviour you see.
Why the children we look after carry so much of it.
A child who was neglected, hit or taken into care concludes that it was because of who they are. Telling them it was not their fault does not reach that.
What shame looks like from the outside.
- rage that seems far too big for what happened
- laughing or smirking at the worst moment
- blaming somebody else, loudly
- denying something you watched them do
- going blank or silent, or leaving the room
- saying “I don’t care”, “I’m rubbish anyway” or “just put me somewhere else then”.
The shame spiral.
The child does something and an adult responds. The child hears “you are bad”, can’t bear it, and does something worse. The adult responds to that and the shame rises again. You can’t win this. Step out of it.
Why the usual responses make shame worse
- Asking for an apology. Saying sorry is a lot to ask of a child who already feels like a bad person. Leave it. Things can be put right without the word.
- “Look at me when I am talking to you.” Let them look away. They can still hear you.
- Asking them to explain themselves. “What were you thinking?” has no answer.
- Correcting them in front of other people. Say it later and in private.
Ask what has already been tried with this child, and consider whether shame is the reason it did not work.
Lowering the shame
Get the shame low enough that the child can hear you. You are still dealing with what happened.
- Name the need. Say “you were really hungry” in place of “you stole food again”.
- Get alongside the child. Sit next to them, walk with them, or talk in the car.
- Keep your face and voice warm while you hold the boundary.
- Come back later. When everyone is calm, return to it briefly.
- Let them save face. Offer a job, change the subject, or leave the room so they can come out without an audience.
Agree with your supervising social worker what you are trying, for how long, and what would show you it is working.
Naming feelings
Children who can’t say what they feel.
Some children have three words for everything: fine, bored, angry. They may describe a feeling as a tummy ache. Naming feelings is taught, and a child who had nobody doing that arrives without the words, so “how do you feel?” gets you nothing.
Teaching the words.
- Name it for them, as a guess: “I think you might be fed up.” Don’t require them to agree.
- Name your own feelings out loud: “I’m getting frustrated, so I’m going to leave it for ten minutes.”
- Use characters. A child will often discuss what the person in the programme, or the dog, is feeling.
- Teach the sizes of a feeling: annoyed, cross, furious.
- Ask where in their body they feel it.
- Accept “I don’t know”.
Reading other people.
Some children assume the worst from a neutral face. Say out loud what your face is doing: “I’m frowning because I’m reading something annoying. It isn’t you.” See also Staying calm.
Linking the feeling to the behaviour.
Afterwards, tell it as a story: “I think you were starving by the time we got in, and then the thing with the shoes happened, and it all went up from there.” Say it once. Don’t ask them to confirm it and don’t add what they should have done.
When a child can’t do the schoolwork
Being behind, and knowing it.
Many of the children we look after are behind at school, and they know it. They conclude that they are stupid, and that belief drives a lot of school refusal and refusal to try.
What it looks like.
- behaviour that gets the child out of the room before the work starts
- destroying their own work, or saying it is rubbish before anyone else can
- refusing to try anything new, including things they would enjoy
- claiming not to care
- great distress over a small mistake
- never asking for help.
What helps.
- Deal with the shame first. No child learns while they feel humiliated.
- Give the true explanation, more than once: “You missed a lot of school. That’s why this is hard.”
- Don’t let homework become a battle. If it is damaging your evenings, speak to the school.
- Work at the level they are at.
- Ask for assessment in writing, in the child’s personal education plan and at the review. The education policy explains the plan.
- Help them get good at something that is not schoolwork. See Belonging, confidence and friendships.
- Tell the school what you have noticed and ask what support is in place.