Trauma, Loss and the Developing Child

2.1 The main points

Trauma is rarely one event. For most of our children it is something that happened over and over. A child’s brain adapts to the home they were born into. What looks like a problem now kept them safe then. Children often behave much younger than their age. Parent the stage they are at, not their birthday. Some children signal the opposite of what they need, and push you away hardest when they need you most. Children do recover. What helps most is a safe relationship that lasts. If something is happening right now, look it up in Common Challenges: An A-Z.

2.2 What we mean by trauma

Trauma means being hurt or frightened in a way that overwhelms you, at a time when nobody helped. For children who come into foster care, this usually includes some of the following. Being hit or hurt. Being shouted at or threatened. Being left hungry, cold or dirty. Being left alone. Watching one adult hurt another. Living with a parent who was very unwell, using drugs or drinking heavily. Being sexually abused. Living somewhere that was never the same two days running. It also includes being taken into care. Being removed from home is frightening for a child even when it is the right thing to do, and even when the child is relieved. Trauma is rarely a single event. A child who was frightened once, badly, is affected by it. A child who spent four years not knowing which version of their parent would be home is affected differently, and usually more deeply. The second kind is more common in fostering.

2.2.1 Loss counts, even when home was unsafe

Every child in foster care has lost something, and the list is longer than people expect. Their parents. Their brothers and sisters. Their bedroom. Their school. Their friends. Their pets. Their street. Their smells and sounds. Sometimes their language, their food and their religion. Children grieve all of this, including the people who hurt them. This confuses adults, and it should not. You can miss someone and be frightened of them at the same time. A child who cries for a parent who neglected them is not being disloyal to you, and they are not confused. They have lost their mother or their father, and that is a real loss. Some children have also been bereaved. A parent, a brother or sister, a grandparent or a previous carer may have died. Often nobody has ever properly talked to the child about it. Grief that was never acknowledged does not go away, and it tends to arrive later, at the anniversary, or at a funeral on television, or for no reason anyone can see.

Critical Actions — 2. Repeated behaviours

Trauma is rarely one event, so the question to ask about a child’s history is not only what happened but how often, over how long, and whether it ever stopped. A single frightening incident and four years of never knowing who would be home produce different children and need different responses.

2.3 How the brain learns about people

2.3.1 How trust is built

A baby cannot do anything for itself. It can only signal. It cries, and it waits. When an adult comes, picks the baby up, feeds it, changes it and settles it, the baby learns something without words: when I need something, somebody comes. This happens thousands of times in the first two years. Each time, the lesson is laid down a little deeper. That lesson is what we call attachment. It is not about love. It is about what a child has learned to expect from people. A child who has learned that adults come will go on to explore, take risks, make friends and ask for help, because they expect help to arrive.

2.3.2 What happens when nobody comes

Now picture the same baby crying, and nobody coming. Or somebody coming, but angry. Or somebody coming sometimes, and not others, with no pattern the baby can work out. That baby also learns. It learns that adults are not reliable, or are dangerous, or that needing things is pointless. Its brain adapts to the home it is in. The child is not damaged. They are adapted. Staying alert all the time, not trusting adults, grabbing food, keeping quiet, controlling everything they can — these were sensible in the home they came from. They worked. The problem is that the child brings them to your home, where they are no longer needed, and where they get in the way. Nobody told the child the danger has passed. Their body has not caught up.

2.3.3 Patterns of attachment

You may hear four words used to describe what a child has learned. Here is what each looks like at the kitchen table. Secure. The child expects adults to help. They ask for things. They can be comforted when upset. Most children in foster care have not had this, although some have, and it is worth knowing if they have. Avoidant. The child learned that showing a need gets no response, or an irritated one. So they stop showing it. They look independent and undemanding. They say they are fine. They manage their own homework, their own worries, their own illness. Adults often describe these children as easy, and they are the easiest to overlook. Ambivalent. The child learned that help comes sometimes, unpredictably. So they turn the volume up and keep it up, because that is what has occasionally worked. They can seem clingy, demanding, dramatic or impossible to satisfy. When you give them what they asked for, it is often not enough. Disorganised. The child learned that the person they needed was also the person who frightened them. There is no strategy that works for that, because the instinct to run to someone and the instinct to run from them are the same person. These children can look confusing and contradictory: desperate for closeness one minute, attacking it the next. This is the pattern most common in children who have been abused. Most children do not sit neatly in one of these. Do not use them as labels. Use them to ask what a child has learned to expect, and why.

2.3.4 Miscuing

Some children signal the opposite of what they need. This is called miscuing, and it catches out even experienced carers. A child who is frightened pushes you away. A child who wants to be looked after insists they need nothing. A child who is desperate to stay wrecks their room. A child who wants to be held hits you. There is a reason for it. If needing people has gone badly before, then showing a need is dangerous. It is safer to make you go away first, and find out whether you come back. The practical rule is simple. When a child’s behaviour pushes you away hardest, that is usually the moment they most need you to stay. You do not have to get close. You have to not leave.

Critical Actions — 8. Lived experience

Two children with almost identical histories can turn out completely different. The history tells you what happened to them. Only their lived experience tells you what it meant. Start from how this child seems to be experiencing their life now, rather than from what their file would lead you to predict.

2.4 What you will see

2.4.1 Developmental age and birthday age

Children grow up in stages. Each stage needs the one before it. A child learns to trust before they learn to share, and to share before they learn to apologise properly. When a child’s early years were frightening, some of those stages did not happen. The child kept getting older, but parts of them stayed behind. So you may have a twelve-year-old who can do long division and cannot wait five minutes. A fifteen-year-old who wants a lift to town and cries when the biscuit breaks. A nine-year-old who still wants to be fed with a spoon when they are tired. This is not babyish and it is not an act. You are seeing the age they are actually at, in that moment, for that thing. So: parent the stage, not the birthday. If a child is behaving like a three-year-old, then what works for a three-year-old will work: fewer words, more warmth, more help, less expectation that they can manage alone. It also means the same child may need different ages of care at different times of the day. A child can be fourteen at school and four at bedtime. Both are real.

2.4.2 Survival mode

When a child feels in danger, a fast part of the brain takes over before the thinking part gets a say. This is survival mode. It happens in all of us. It happens more often, and more easily, in children who have been frightened a lot. It usually shows up in one of four ways. Fight. Shouting, hitting, throwing, swearing, threatening, destroying things. Flight. Running out of the room, leaving the house, hiding, refusing to come out of their bedroom. Freeze. Going still and silent. Not answering. Staring. Looking blank or vacant. This one is often missed, and the child is often described as rude or ignoring you. Please. Becoming extremely helpful, agreeable and charming. Apologising for everything. Working very hard to keep the adult happy. This one is almost always missed, because it looks like good behaviour. In survival mode a child cannot think clearly, cannot listen to a long explanation, and often cannot remember afterwards what they did or said. There is no point reasoning with a child in this state. Help them come out of it first.

2.4.3 Why consequences do not teach our children

Most parenting advice assumes a child can link what they did to what happened afterwards, remember that link next time, and use it to choose differently. That chain needs three things our children often do not have: the ability to think ahead, a calm enough brain to remember in the moment, and a belief that what they do makes a difference. So a consequence given an hour later lands as something unfair that an adult did to them. It teaches them that adults are unpredictable. It does not teach them to make a different choice. This is not an argument for having no boundaries. It is an argument for understanding why the usual tools do not work, and for using different ones. Connection Before Correction sets out what to do instead.

Critical Actions — 1. Current circumstances

What you are seeing is the presenting information: the first line, not the whole account. Treat survival behaviour as the first piece of evidence you have been handed, and expect it to make sense only once you have the rest.

2.5 Recovery

 Children recover. People talking about trauma often leave that out. What the research keeps finding is not complicated. The thing that helps a child recover is a relationship with an adult who is safe, who is predictable, and who is still there months and years later. Not a technique. Not a programme. A person who keeps turning up. That is what you are. It is also why placements ending early does so much harm, and why staying when things are hard is the most valuable thing a foster carer does. Three things are worth knowing about how recovery actually goes. It is slow. A child spent years learning that adults are not safe. They will not unlearn it in a term. You are looking for change over a year, not a fortnight. It is not a straight line. Children often get worse before they get better, and worse again when things are going well. A child who feels safer may start showing you feelings they had to hide before. That is progress, even though it does not feel like it. You may not see the end of it. Some of what you do will show up years later, with someone else, or when the child is an adult. That is hard. It is still worth doing. The small things repeated are what count. Being there at pick-up. The same words at bedtime. Food that appears without being asked for. Coming back after an argument. None of it looks like much on any given day, and all of it is the work.

2.6 Where to find out more

 Beacon House publishes free one-page explanations of trauma and the brain, written for carers and easy to print. Many carers put them on the fridge. The UK Trauma Council has free animations and short videos that explain what happens in the brain after frightening experiences. Start with the one on childhood trauma and the brain. The Secure Base website explains the five dimensions in more detail, with examples. Our own Additional resources page lists the books we recommend, the therapeutic games and card decks you can buy with your training and events allowance, and the online courses available to you. If you would rather talk it through than read, ask your supervising social worker to go through this page with you. That is part of their job, not a favour.