Common Challenges: An A–Z

Each entry covers

What it usually means What helps What makes it worse When to escalate Critical Actions — the framework in miniature. Each entry follows the same order: what is happening now, has it happened before, what have you already tried, what will you try next. Use an entry to form a view rather than to find a technique.

The entries

16.2.1 Anger and rage

What it usually means. Fear underneath, nearly always. A child in a rage is a child whose body believes it is in danger, and the anger is the protection. It may also be the only feeling they have a word for, so grief, shame and panic all come out looking like anger. What helps. Fewer words. Lower voice. More space. Removing the audience. Staying nearby without asking anything of them. Naming the feeling rather than the behaviour. Leaving the room yourself if you need to, saying that you are coming back. What makes it worse. Reasoning during it. Raising your voice. Standing over them. Adding a new demand. Threatening something you will not carry out. Bringing up previous incidents. Asking why. When to escalate. Injury to anybody. Damage that is frightening rather than annoying. Rages getting longer, more frequent, or harder to come out of. Anything that leaves you afraid in your own home. Say it in supervision the same week rather than waiting for the next session.

16.2.2 Bedtime and sleep

What it usually means. Night is when bad things happened for a lot of children. Being alone in the dark with nothing to do but think is the hardest part of the day. Resisting bedtime is usually resisting being alone rather than resisting sleep. What helps. The same routine in the same order every night. A long wind-down rather than a sharp cut-off. Light on, door open, landing light, a radio, your voice within earshot. Saying you will check on them, and then actually doing it. Letting them fall asleep somewhere else and moving them, if that is what works for now. What makes it worse. Sending them up as a consequence. Shutting the door on a frightened child. Insisting on a lights-off time they cannot manage. Screens right up to bedtime. Taking away the comfort object because they are too old for it. When to escalate. Sleep that does not improve over months. Nightmares most nights. A child who cannot be left at all. Daytime exhaustion. Anything suggesting the nights hold something specific. Bring a record of what the nights actually look like.

16.2.3 Birthdays and presents

What it usually means. A birthday belongs to a child’s family as much as to them, and it is often the day they most expect to hear from somebody. Presents can be unbearable for a child who does not believe they deserve things, or who is waiting for the catch. Some children have been given things and then had them used against them. What helps. Asking well in advance what they want the day to be, and being ready for the answer to be nothing. Keeping it small unless they want big. Saying out loud that their family may be in their mind today. Giving presents without ceremony and without an audience watching their reaction. What makes it worse. A surprise party. Opening things in front of people. Expecting gratitude. Treating a flat reaction as ingratitude. Promising contact with family on the day that you cannot deliver. When to escalate. Birthdays that reliably produce a crisis, so that next year can be planned. Expectations about family contact that are not in the plan. Write down what happened and when, because birthdays come round again.

16.2.4 Bullying, in both directions

What it usually means. Children in care are bullied more than other children: for being different, for where they live, for something somebody’s parent said. A child who bullies others is usually passing on what they have had, or managing their own fear by being the one in charge. What helps. Believing them immediately. Acting, and telling the child what you did: the school, in writing, with a date for a reply. Keeping track of it rather than assuming it has been dealt with. Where your child is the one bullying, dealing with it without turning it into evidence of what they are. What makes it worse. Telling a child to ignore it or to stand up for themselves. Treating being bullied as the child’s social skills problem. Punishing a child who has bullied without working out what they are protecting themselves from. When to escalate. Anything physical. Anything online. Anything the school has not dealt with after you raised it. Any bullying that refers to their being in care, which schools routinely underestimate.

16.2.5 Clubs and activities a child sabotages

What it usually means. Quitting just as it starts to go well, often straight after praise, or after being picked, or after being good at something. A child who does not believe good things last will frequently end them first. Some are also protecting themselves from being seen to fail. What helps. One thing rather than several. Committing to a set number of sessions before deciding anything. Being there. Low-key noticing rather than praise. Paying for the term up front, so that stopping is not the easy option. What makes it worse. Praising hard. Telling them how much potential they have. Making it about your investment in it. Letting them quit the week it gets difficult. Signing them up for something you want for them. When to escalate. A pattern of quitting everything, which is worth naming as a finding rather than treating as a series of unconnected decisions.

16.2.6 Controlling behaviour

What it usually means. A child who has had no control over anything important will take control of whatever is available. Food, routines, their room, what you say, where people sit, what happens next. It is anxiety management rather than defiance, and it gets worse whenever something big is uncertain. What helps. Giving real control somewhere else, deliberately and generously. Keeping the day predictable, so there is less that needs controlling. Saying what is happening before it happens. Holding firm on the few things that matter and letting a lot of the rest go. What makes it worse. Fighting every instance. Winning on principle. Surprise changes. Vague answers about what is happening later. When to escalate. Control that is frightening another child in the house, or that is aimed at another child rather than at the household arrangements.

16.2.7 Difficulty after contact

What it usually means. The child has had their whole history put back in front of them, and the behaviour afterwards is the overflow. It is usually not about the session itself, and it can be worse when contact went well. What helps. Nothing planned for the rest of the day. Food, a bath, something familiar. No questions at the door. You nearby and undemanding. Lowering every other expectation for that day and often the next one. What makes it worse. Asking how it went. Discussing the parent. Any consequence for behaviour in the hours afterwards. Treating the state as a verdict on contact in front of the child. When to escalate. Record before and after, every time, with dates. Raise it once a pattern is clear, whether or not the pattern supports contact continuing.

16.2.8 Eating, hoarding and food refusal

What it usually means. Food is rarely about food. Hunger that was never met leaves a child unable to trust that food will come, so they hoard, hide, take, eat enormous amounts, or cannot stop. Refusing food is often the only refusal available to them. Food may also have been used as a reward or a punishment. What helps. Visible, constant, unlimited access to something. A bowl of food in their room that gets refilled without comment. Never remarking on quantity. Meals at predictable times. Letting them serve themselves. Leaving hoards alone and quietly replacing anything that has spoiled. What makes it worse. Removing food. Rationing. Commenting on how much they eat. Making eating a condition of anything. Clearing out a hidden store. Arguing at the table. When to escalate. Weight changes, anything that looks as though it has become about the body rather than about safety, or refusal that is affecting health. That goes to the child’s social worker and to health rather than being managed at home.

16.2.9 Going missing or running away, and the return

What it usually means. Running towards something as often as away from something. A parent, a sibling, a friend, a place that felt like theirs. Sometimes it is an escape from a feeling that has become unbearable in the house. Sometimes somebody outside is encouraging it. What helps. The return. How you are in the first ten minutes decides whether they tell you anything and whether they come back next time. Food, warmth, a bath, bed, nothing else. Say you are glad they are back and mean it. The conversation happens the next day or later. What makes it worse. An interrogation at the door. A consequence on arrival. Shouting, even from relief. Making them account for themselves while cold and frightened. Threats about what happens if they do it again. When to escalate. Every single time, through the missing child procedures, without exception. Then separately: patterns in where they go and who they are with, which is often the first visible sign of exploitation.

16.2.10 Homework and school refusal

What it usually means. Very often shame about not being able to do the work rather than unwillingness to do it. Sometimes exhaustion, because holding it together through a school day takes everything. Sometimes something specific at school that nobody has asked about. What helps. Treating refusal as information and asking what is happening at school. Ten minutes rather than an hour. Sitting alongside them. Working at the level they are actually at. Telling the school when homework is not happening and why, rather than fighting it at home. What makes it worse. Making it a battle. Consequences attached to homework. Comparing them with another child. Forcing a child into school while visibly terrified, which may get them through one morning and set them back for a term. When to escalate. More than a few days missed. Any refusal that is building rather than passing. Ask for an assessment and for it to be in the personal education plan, and bring dated examples.

16.2.11 Hygiene refusal

What it usually means. Washing involves being undressed, alone, and vulnerable, which is unbearable for some children. Some were never taught. Some have learned that being unappealing keeps people away, which can be deliberate protection. Some have sensory difficulty with water, temperature or smells. What helps. Removing the audience and the argument. Giving choices about how rather than whether: bath or shower, morning or evening, door open, music on, your own choice of products. Teaching it properly rather than assuming they know. Keeping it brief and unremarked. What makes it worse. Comments about how they smell, from anybody. Making it a condition of going out. Forcing it. Discussing it where others can hear. Treating it as laziness. When to escalate. Sudden change in a child who managed before. Hygiene refusal alongside covering the body or not wanting to be seen. Anything that is affecting health or leading to them being excluded by other children.

16.2.12 Hypervigilance

What it usually means. A child whose body is still scanning for danger. Watching your face, flinching at noise, needing to see the door, knowing where everybody in the house is, unable to settle with their back to a room, exhausted by the end of the day. It is not nosiness or anxiety in the ordinary sense. It kept them alive. What helps. Predictability above everything. Saying what is happening and when. Being the same person every day. Letting them sit where they want. Keeping the house noise low and even. Telling them where you are going and when you will be back, including inside the house. What makes it worse. Sudden noise and sudden entrances. Changing plans without telling them. Being inconsistent in mood. Doors closed and conversations they cannot hear. Telling them they have nothing to worry about. When to escalate. Hypervigilance that is not easing over months, or that is stopping them sleeping or learning. It is worth naming specifically, because it is often recorded as anxiety and treated as the child’s personality.

16.2.13 Lying

What it usually means. Rarely about deceiving you. A child may be unable to tolerate being the person who did it. A child may be telling you what they think will keep them safe, which is what lying was for at home. Some lying is wishful rather than deceptive: the holiday they did not go on, the family they do not have. What helps. Not setting traps and not asking questions you already know the answer to. Dealing with the thing rather than the lie. Giving them a way to put it right without admitting anything. Letting the wishful ones go, or wondering aloud gently about what they wish were true. What makes it worse. Demanding a confession. Catching them out. Calling them a liar. Punishing the lie more heavily than the act, which simply teaches better lying. When to escalate. Lying that puts them or another child at risk. Any account that changes in a way that might matter for safeguarding. Record what was said, in their words, and pass it on rather than deciding what is true.

16.2.14 Medical and dental appointments

What it usually means. Being touched by a stranger, in a room, without control over what happens next. For a child who has been hurt, that is the shape of the thing they are most frightened of. Many have also had painful or neglected dental and medical histories, and some have had appointments used as threats. What helps. Telling them exactly what will happen, in order, beforehand. Going to look at the building first for a child who needs that. Staying in the room. Telling the practitioner in advance, briefly, that this child needs things explained and needs to be asked before being touched. Agreeing a way for the child to stop it. What makes it worse. Springing it on them. Saying it will not hurt when it might. Holding a child still. Letting a practitioner proceed without speaking to the child. Treating refusal as naughtiness. When to escalate. Appointments that cannot happen at all, including dental, which is a health need rather than a behaviour problem. Ask for help from the child’s social worker and the health team rather than repeatedly failing to get them through the door.

16.2.15 Public places

What it usually means. Supermarkets and similar places are loud, bright, crowded and full of things a child wants and cannot have. For a child with sensory needs or no capacity to wait, they are unmanageable before anything happens. The school gate adds an audience. What helps. Short trips, planned, not when anybody is hungry or tired. Giving them a job. Taking a list. Leaving before it goes wrong rather than after. Deciding in advance what you will do if it does, and being willing to abandon the shopping. What makes it worse. Long trips. Bargaining. Threats you cannot carry out in public. Escalating because you are embarrassed. When a stranger intervenes. Somebody will comment, and occasionally somebody will threaten to report you. Say as little as possible, do not explain the child’s history to anybody, do not enter an argument in front of the child, and leave. Then tell your supervising social worker the same day and write down what happened, including what was said and by whom. That record protects you if an allegation follows. Carers’ own allegations are covered in Looking After Yourself.

16.2.16 Rejecting you

What it usually means. A child pushing away the person they are starting to need. Closeness is dangerous if everyone who has been close to you has hurt or left you, so a child who is beginning to attach will often attack it. It frequently follows a good week, a kindness, or a moment of real closeness. What helps. Not taking it at face value and not withdrawing in return. Carrying on exactly as before: the tea, the lift, the goodnight. Saying the plain thing once. “You can be as cross with me as you like. I’m still here.” Then leaving it. What makes it worse. Matching their coldness. Being hurt at them. Asking what you have done wrong. Pulling back to protect yourself, which confirms the whole theory. When to escalate. When it is wearing you down, which it will. Say it in supervision rather than absorbing it, because this is the thing that quietly ends placements. Blocked care is covered in Looking After Yourself.

16.2.17 Sabotage, especially when things are going well

What it usually means. A child ending the good thing before it can be taken away. Good days, new things, holidays, praise and progress are all unbearable for a child who is certain it will not last, and ending it themselves is at least something they control. What helps. Expecting it, and naming it quietly to yourself rather than to the child in the moment. Keeping the good thing available afterwards rather than withdrawing it. Saying a version of the truth later: “Good days can feel strange. The day is still a good day.” Keeping your own reaction small. What makes it worse. Pointing out how much they have ruined it. Cancelling the next one. Expressing disappointment, which is the exact feeling they were trying to get over with. When to escalate. When the pattern is reliable enough to plan around, so that the holiday or the birthday can be set up differently next time.

16.2.18 Saying they are not happy here and want to leave

What it usually means. Often not a request to move. It can be a test of whether you will send them away, a way of leaving before being left, a reaction to something that happened today, loyalty to their family, or the only sentence big enough for how they feel. What helps. Taking it seriously without treating it as a decision. “That sounds like a horrible way to feel. Tell me about it.” Asking what would make it better here. Saying plainly that you are not sending them anywhere, if that is true. Coming back to it the next day when things are calm. What makes it worse. Panicking. Defending your house. Listing what you have done for them. Saying you will have to tell their social worker as though it were a threat. Agreeing that they should go, said in temper. When to escalate. Always pass it on, and say that you have. A child saying this repeatedly is a finding, whatever you make of it, and so is a child saying it once and meaning it. If there is something behind it about your household, it has to go to somebody who is not you.

16.2.19 Screens and phones

What it usually means. For many children a phone is the only private thing they have, the only control they have, and the route to their family. It may also be how somebody outside is reaching them. Screens are frequently the one reliable way a child has of settling themselves. What helps. Treating the phone as theirs rather than as a privilege you lend them. Clear expectations agreed in advance rather than invented in an argument. Winding down before bed rather than switching off at bedtime. Being genuinely interested in what they do on it. What makes it worse. Confiscation as a consequence, which removes the thing that regulates them and the route to their family at once. Random searches. Reading their messages without telling them. Banning contact with family they are reaching, rather than passing it on. When to escalate. Anybody unknown in contact with them. Money or items appearing. Secrecy that is new. Anything frightening them. This goes to the social worker, and the online safety policy applies.

16.2.20 Sibling conflict

What it usually means. Siblings arrive with roles already formed in a household that was not safe, and they compete for a scarce adult. The competing often gets worse rather than better once the adult is reliable, because now there is something worth winning. One child may also have been given authority over the other. What helps. Time with each of them separately, regularly, which is the thing that makes the difference. Taking the parenting role off the older one gradually. Giving each of them something that is theirs. Separate bedrooms and separate bedtimes where possible. What makes it worse. Treating them as a unit. Asking the older one to help. Praising the older one for being responsible. Making them share the thing they fight over. Working out who started it. When to escalate. When one child is frightened of the other, which is not rivalry. When one is controlling the other. When either is being hurt. Say it early, while there are still options.

16.2.21 Soiling and wetting

What it usually means. Almost never deliberate. It is extremely common in children who have been through trauma and neglect, and it can continue well past the age people expect. Causes include a body that is permanently braced, a nervous system that cannot register the signal, a medical cause, constipation, never having been taught, and fear of the toilet or the bathroom. What helps. Treating it as a health matter, not a behaviour matter. No reaction at all: change it, clean it, carry on, briefly and kindly. Keeping spare clothes everywhere. Getting a GP appointment, because constipation is a very common and very treatable cause. Keeping it entirely private from everybody else in the house. What makes it worse. Any consequence. Making them clean it up as a lesson. Sighing. Telling anybody else. Asking why they did not go. Withdrawing drinks. When to escalate. Always go to the GP, and ask for a referral if it continues. Also raise a sudden start in a child who was dry, which can mean something has happened.

16.2.22 Stealing

What it usually means. Usually food, money, or small things belonging to somebody else. It tends to be about having something of your own, or hunger that is no longer about food, or needing something solid to hold when everything else is uncertain. Some children take from the person they are closest to, which is about the relationship rather than the object. What helps. Dealing with the item quietly and without an audience. Making the thing available so it does not need taking: money of their own, food they can help themselves to, something that is theirs. Putting it right in a small practical way rather than through a confession. What makes it worse. Searching their room. Interrogation. Calling them a thief. Telling the household. A consequence far bigger than the thing taken. When to escalate. Stealing outside the house, anything involving a shop or the police, or amounts that suggest somebody else is involved. Record it factually and pass it on.

16.2.23 Swearing and verbal abuse

What it usually means. Often the only language a child has for a feeling that size, and sometimes exactly the language used at home. Abuse aimed at you specifically is usually aimed at the role rather than the person, and it is frequently a test of whether you will leave. What helps. Not reacting to the words. Responding to the feeling underneath, briefly. Saying the house rule once, calmly, when everybody is settled, not during. Leaving the room rather than trading. Repairing afterwards, from your side first. What makes it worse. Shouting back. Taking it personally out loud. A consequence for each word. Demanding an apology. Discussing it while they are still in it. When to escalate. Threats you believe. Abuse directed at another child in the house. Anything with a racist, religious or other targeted element, which is a different matter and goes on the record as such. And any abuse that is affecting your own wellbeing, which is a supervision item in its own right.

16.2.24 Transitions and endings of activities

What it usually means. Stopping one thing and starting another requires knowing what comes next and trusting that it will be all right, and both are hard for our children. The transition itself is the problem, not the activity being ended. Screens are hardest because they also turn off the thing that was settling them. What helps. Warning, and then warning again. Counting it down. The same words each time. A few minutes of nothing between one thing and the next rather than going straight from one to another. A clear what-happens-next, said out loud. What makes it worse. No warning. Going straight from school to homework. Doing it in a hurry. Varying the words and the sequence. Treating the resistance as being about the activity. When to escalate. When one particular transition goes wrong every single time. That is useful information rather than a daily battle, and it belongs in supervision so the day can be rearranged around it.