Auditing a Child's Therapeutic Support Needs

What this is for

This is a checklist for working out what a child actually needs, rather than responding to what they are doing. Use it when a placement is new and you are building a picture. Use it when something has stopped working and you cannot say why. Use it before a review, a team around the child meeting, or a request for extra support, because it turns a general sense that things are hard into something other people can act on. It follows the fifteen sections of Critical Actions. That is the same structure as our assessment and review paperwork, and the same structure you meet in training, so what you write here can go straight into those documents. Critical Actions is a framework for analysing risk and need and reaching a decision. It is not an intervention and it does not replace a statutory assessment or a specialist one. What it does is stop a household working harder on the wrong explanation. It is not a form to be completed in order, and not every question applies to every child.

How to use it

Work through it with someone. Your supervising social worker, your co-carer, or your supervision session. The value is in the conversation, not in filling in boxes. Say when you do not know. “I do not know” is a finding, and it is often the most useful one on the page. Write dates and examples, not impressions. “Refuses to go to school” is an impression. “Got as far as the gate and came home on the 14th, 16th and 17th” is a finding. Keep what you have seen separate from what you have concluded. Both matter, and they are not the same thing. Do it again later. An audit at the start of a placement is a snapshot. The same audit three months on shows direction, which is more useful than either on its own.

The audit

18.3.1 Current circumstances

What is happening now, this week, around this child. What happened in the ten minutes before, rather than only what the child did? What changed this week for everybody else in the house: a new placement, a carer back at work, an exam year, illness, somebody moving in? Where in the day does it go wrong, and what is happening at that hour? Is the room itself part of it: the noise, the light, the label in the collar, the smell of the food? Where are we in the contact cycle, and in the court timetable if there is one? What date is coming up that this child’s body may remember even if they do not?

18.3.2 Repeated behaviours

What keeps happening, and whether it is moving in either direction. What is the shape of it from the first sign to the end, and where is the earliest point we could act? How often, how badly, how long, and is any of those three increasing? Does it happen for other adults, at school, with other children, or only here? Are the ordinary days recorded as well as the incidents? A file of only incidents makes every child look permanently in crisis. Did this happen in previous placements, and is it written down anywhere? Is it the same behaviour in the same situation, or the same behaviour everywhere?

18.3.3 Identity

Who this child understands themselves to be, assessed rather than assumed. Does this child know their own story, in a form they can hold at the age they are now? Food, hair and skin care, language, prayer, the calendar, how their name is said: which of these is actively provided for, and which is being assumed? Do they have anything of their own from before: photographs, belongings, a memory box? Do they believe they belong in this family, and how do we know that rather than assume it? Who in their actual life, rather than in principle, shares their heritage? Is being in care becoming the identity that swallows the others?

18.3.4 Triangulation

What other people see, and whether it matches what we see. What does school see, and have we asked rather than waited to be told? What do the child’s social worker, the independent reviewing officer, health and any therapist see? What does birth family see and say? Where do these accounts disagree, and what would explain the difference? Who has known this child longest, and have we spoken to them? Whose account of this child is missing from the picture altogether?

18.3.5 Interventions completed

What has already been tried, by this household and by everyone before it. What have we tried, for how long, and what happened? What helped, even briefly? This is the most useful thing in a child’s file and the most often missing from it. What did previous carers try, and is any of it recorded? What has school tried, what did they stop doing, and why? What support or therapy has this child already had, did it finish or stop, and how did they experience it? What are we still doing that is no longer achieving anything?

18.3.6 Compliance and capacity for change

What this child is able to do, as distinct from willing to do. Is this child choosing not to, or unable to? From outside, both look the same. Have they shown they can do it in any setting, ever? Are our expectations matched to their developmental age rather than their birthday? Is an unassessed need in the way: attention, working memory, understanding, language, hearing, sight, sensory? Would a therapeutic approach on its own reach this, or does the task and the environment have to change as well? Where a parent is involved: what did they actually do, as distinct from whether we believe they have changed?

18.3.7 Agency

What this child has real control over. Where does this child have genuine influence over something that matters to them? What choices do they get in a day, and would we honour the answer if it were inconvenient? Have they been asked their view, was it recorded, and did anything visibly follow from it? Do they know who to tell if they are unhappy, and do they believe it would make any difference? Are the battles over small things telling us there is nothing real for them to control? If the honest answer to all of this is nowhere, that is the finding to act on. Would this child benefit from an advocate, and has anybody told them that advocates exist?

18.3.8 Lived experience

What this is like from inside the child. What is this like from in there? What does this child think is happening, and what do they think happens next? What do they believe about why they are in care, and whether it was their fault? Can they name what they are feeling, and if not, how many words do they actually have for it? What have we checked with them, in their own words, rather than assumed? What are they frightened of that nobody has said out loud? What does this child find comforting, and is it available to them in this house?

18.3.9 Analysis

What we think is going on, and what it rests on. What is our best explanation for this, in two sentences? What is the second most likely explanation? Could this be trauma, neurodivergence, or both, and what evidence sits on each side? Could this be an unmet need rather than a behaviour: hunger, pain, tiredness, sensory overload, not having understood the instruction? Is shame doing the work here, and if so what is the child avoiding having to admit? What are we assuming because it was in the file on the day the child arrived? What would we expect to see if we are right, and what would show us we are wrong?

18.3.10 Crisis indicators

What tells us this is getting worse rather than being difficult. What are this child’s early warning signs, in the order they appear? What is different about this child when things are deteriorating, as opposed to simply hard? What are the indicators visible from outside: sleep, appetite, the phone, money and items appearing, new friends nobody has met, withdrawal? What would make us ring out of hours, and does everybody in the household know that? Are the carer’s own warning signs on this list too: avoiding the room, counting the days, going through the motions, relief when the child goes out? Is anything escalating in how often, how badly, or how long it lasts?

18.3.11 Thresholds

Where the lines are, and whose lines they are. At what point does this stop being manageable in this home? What is the threshold for the other children in the household, which is a different one and usually lower? Is something being tolerated that should not be, because it is understandable given the child’s history? Both of those can be true at once. Is something being escalated that is within normal range for a child who has been through this? What is the carer’s own threshold, and has it been said out loud to anybody? Is anything waiting for somebody to feel sure before it gets passed on? Deciding whether it is serious enough is not the carer’s job.

18.3.12 Interventions to implement

What is going to happen next, specifically. What are we doing differently, and starting when? What needs to change in the environment and in the demands, rather than in the child? Is this a need that parenting can meet, or one that needs people with training this guidance does not give? When therapeutic care is not enough on its own covers that honestly. What support has been asked for, when, from whom, and what came back? If there is a waiting list, what is happening in the meantime? What are we going to stop doing, as well as start? Who owns each action, and by when?

18.3.13 Oversight

Who else knows, and who is checking. Who knows about this besides the carer? Is it in the recording, or only in somebody’s head? When was it last discussed in supervision, and what was agreed? Who is checking whether the plan is working, and when will they check? What has not been told to anybody, and why not? Is anybody checking on the carer as well as on the child? Blocked care is an oversight matter, not a private one.

18.3.14 Notifications

What has to be told to whom, and what that releases. What needs notifying, to whom, by when, and has it been done in writing? Is the child’s social worker working from current information, or from something months old? Does school know what they need to know, and nothing they do not? What support has not arrived because nobody formally said that the need exists? Does the care plan describe what is actually happening in this house? Is notifying being treated as recording a concern, or as the thing that gets a child the right level of support? It is the second.

18.3.15 Signatures

Who has owned this, and whether anybody can see the whole picture. Who signed off the current plan, and did they see all of it? Does the record show who decided what, and when? Could somebody reading this file in six months see why these decisions were made? If this child moved tomorrow, would the next carer have what we wish we had been given? Did a named person explain the current plan to the child, and did anybody write down what the child said back? Is anybody looking at this child’s whole picture, or only at their own part of it?

Worked example: analysing a referral

The four examples that follow are invented. The children do not exist and the details are made up, so that nothing here is a real child’s business. This first one is deliberately done before a child arrives, because that is where it does the most good, and where it is most often skipped.

The referral.

The referral is for a boy of seven. He came into care at five, after neglect at home, and he has been with the same carers ever since. Those carers have now given notice, and the reason given is that one of them is retiring. He has a younger sister, who lives with a different family. He sees his mother once a fortnight, and those visits are supervised. This would be his second placement. The whole of what the referral says about what he is like is this: settled at school, no concerns, can be a bit boisterous.

1. Current circumstances.

The placement is ending and we have been given a reason. Check it. Ask when notice was given and what happened in the month before. Placements often end for reasons other than the one given, and the month before notice was served is usually where that shows.

2. Repeated behaviours.

He is seven, this would be his second placement, and the referral says nothing at all about why the first one ended. That needs asking before anything else. And the only behaviour described anywhere in a document covering two years of his life is that he can be a bit boisterous.

3. Identity.

Nothing about culture, religion, language, food, hair or skin care. That is missing information, not an absent need. Ask before saying yes, because the answer may be something this household cannot currently provide.

4. Triangulation.

Three accounts exist and we hold none of them: the current carer, the school, the child’s social worker. The line about school could have come from any of the three, at any point in the last two years, and it may well be a summary of a summary. Ask the school what they see at the gate in the morning and at half past three.

5. Interventions completed.

This part of the picture is empty. He has been in care for two years, a placement is now ending, and there is nothing recorded about what has been tried with him or about what helps. Ask the current carer what settles him, because that single answer will tell you more than the rest of the document does.

6. Compliance and capacity for change.

There is no way to answer this before meeting him, and that is a reasonable place to be. Write it down as unknown, so that the silence does not get read later as everything being fine.

7. Agency.

Does he know he is moving, and has anybody asked him anything about it? Ask what he has been told, and by whom.

8. Lived experience.

This cannot be answered yet either, and saying so is part of the analysis rather than a hole in it. What can be asked now is what he himself has said about the move, and who he said it to.

9. Analysis.

On what we have: a seven-year-old losing his second home, told it is because somebody is retiring, living apart from his sister, with no record anywhere of what helps him. The likely picture is a child who will arrive expecting to be moved again and who will test that early. Second explanation, equally live: something ended this placement that is not written down.

10. Crisis indicators.

None are given, and that is not the same as there being none. Ask directly whether there has been any violence, whether he has ever gone missing, and whether there have been any allegations. Those three are not always offered unless somebody asks for them.

11. Thresholds.

Decide now what this household would do if the boisterousness turns out to be something larger, and what the threshold is for the children already here. Deciding that after he arrives is deciding it too late.

12. Interventions to implement.

If we say yes, there are four things for the first week. Raise contact with his sister straight away, in writing. Put the identity questions formally rather than in conversation. Find out where his life story work has got to and who is holding it. And ask for his current carers to meet us before he moves, rather than on the day he moves.

13. Oversight.

Agree now what goes into the first supervision and what the first review has to cover.

14. Notifications.

Sibling contact and the absence of identity information both need raising formally rather than in conversation, because formal is what gets them resourced.

15. Signatures.

Ask who signed the current plan and whether it has been reviewed since notice was given. If it was written before notice was given, it describes a situation that no longer exists.

What the analysis produced.

Not a yes and not a no. Six questions that have to be answered before either, and two findings that will need acting on wherever he goes.

Worked example: a baby who will not settle

The situation.

Nura is eight months old and arrived at five months, after being looked after by a mother who was very unwell. She cries for long stretches, will not be put down, wakes four or five times a night and feeds poorly. The carer has had six weeks of broken sleep and says she is starting to dread the evenings.

1. Current circumstances.

The nights have been getting worse for three weeks. In the same three weeks the carer’s own daughter started a new school year, the health visitor appointment was cancelled and rebooked twice, and feeds moved to being given in the bouncer because the carer was holding two children at once.

2. Repeated behaviours.

It is every night, not some nights. The waking is at the same two points. Nothing about the days has been recorded, so there is no baseline to compare it against.

3. Identity.

Nura is a Somali baby in a white household. Nobody has asked what she was fed, what she was dressed in, what was sung to her, or what her name is short for. Her hair has not been cared for since she arrived, because nobody said anything and the carer did not know to ask.

4. Triangulation.

The health visitor has seen her twice and recorded weight only. The mother has not been asked anything about how Nura slept at home. Nobody has spoken to the foster carer who had her for the first fortnight.

5. Interventions completed.

A later bedtime, a white noise machine, and controlled crying for four nights on a friend’s advice. The fourth of those made it considerably worse and has been stopped. None of it is written down.

6. Compliance and capacity for change.

Not applicable to a baby in the usual sense, but the equivalent question is: can she settle herself? No. She has never had anybody do it with her, so there is nothing to draw on.

7. Agency.

A baby’s version of this is whether her signals produce a response. For the first five months they mostly did not.

8. Lived experience.

From inside: crying for a long time and nobody coming has already been learned once. Being put down is the thing that most reliably produces distress, which tells us what being put down has previously meant.

9. Analysis.

Best explanation: a baby who learned that nobody comes, placed with somebody who does come, and who is now protesting every separation because closeness has become possible and is therefore worth fighting for. The controlled crying confirmed the original lesson and set it back. Second explanation, which has to be ruled out and has not been: pain. Reflux, an ear infection, teeth, or a hearing problem. Nobody has looked.

10. Crisis indicators.

They are in the carer rather than the baby. Dread before the evening, six weeks of broken sleep, and the phrase “I’m starting to resent her”, said once and not followed up. That is the finding on this page that needs acting on first.

11. Thresholds.

The carer is closer to the end of what she can do than anybody has registered, because the baby is the one being discussed. The household threshold here is not about Nura’s behaviour, it is about sleep.

12. Interventions to implement.

GP appointment this week to rule out pain and check hearing. Every feed held, in arms, with eye contact, and no feeding in the bouncer. Go every time she cries, quickly, which is the opposite of what she has had. Same order and same words every night. Record the nights for a fortnight so there is something to analyse. And get practical night cover in, because none of the rest of it survives a carer running on four hours.

13. Oversight.

This needs a supervision this week rather than at the next scheduled one, and it needs to be about the carer as much as the baby.

14. Notifications.

The missed health visitor appointments, the absence of a developmental baseline, and the hair and skin care need raising formally. The last one is an identity need going unmet and it will not get resourced by being mentioned in passing.

15. Signatures.

Nobody has owned the health question. The analysis is only safe once a doctor has excluded pain, and at the moment no named person is responsible for making that happen.

What the analysis produced.

Three actions, in order: rule out pain, get the carer some sleep, and change what happens at every feed. The night waking is how we will know whether any of it is working. It is not the thing to work on directly.

Worked example: a ten-year-old who is soiling

The situation.

Dami is ten and has been in this placement fourteen months. He soils most days, usually in the afternoon, and hides the clothes. He denies it when asked. His carer has started to find it hard not to react, and his own bedroom smells. He has been described in two recorded entries as doing it deliberately.

1. Current circumstances.

It happens at home, in the afternoon, and almost never at school. It got worse eleven weeks ago. In that week his contact moved from fortnightly to weekly and a final hearing date was set.

2. Repeated behaviours.

Daily, same part of the day, fourteen months with no recorded break. It happened in his previous placement too, which is in the file as one line and was never followed up. Nothing records the days it does not happen.

3. Identity.

Being the boy who smells is becoming what he is, at home and increasingly at school. Another child in the house has mentioned it to a friend. His own account of himself has started to include it.

4. Triangulation.

School says it has happened twice there in a year. Nobody has asked the previous carer. The GP has seen him once, for something else. His mother has not been asked whether this happened when he lived with her.

5. Interventions completed.

Reminders to go, a reward chart, and for three weeks being asked to rinse the clothes himself. The chart ran for a month and made no difference. The rinsing has stopped. None of the three is written down as having been tried.

6. Compliance and capacity for change.

The file says deliberate. Nothing supports that. A child who could control this and was choosing not to would not be hiding the evidence. Hiding it is the strongest indication available that he cannot control it and is ashamed.

7. Agency.

He has no say in contact, which has just changed, and no say in the hearing. Almost the only thing in his life he currently affects is whether adults are pleased with him, and that is going badly.

8. Lived experience.

From inside: something happens to his body that he cannot predict or stop, adults keep asking him about it, and he has worked out that the answer they want is that he is sorry. He has never been asked whether it hurts.

9. Analysis.

Best explanation: constipation, which is extremely common, produces exactly this pattern, and has never been excluded, with shame then driving the hiding and the denial. The timing points to the second element, which is that the change in contact and the hearing date have raised his anxiety and his body is carrying it. The “deliberate” entry is a conclusion that arrived early and has been copied forward. Nobody has looked for a cause because the behaviour reading arrived first.

10. Crisis indicators.

The carer’s reaction is changing, which is the thing moving fastest. Other children in the house now know. Both of those will reach him before any treatment does.

11. Thresholds.

Two separate ones. His, which is health, and the other children’s, which is that this is becoming something he is known for inside the household. The second one has already been crossed and nobody has registered it.

12. Interventions to implement.

GP this week, explicitly to look for constipation, and a request for a continence referral. Stop every reminder, every chart and every conversation about it. No reaction at all: change it, deal with it, carry on, briefly and kindly. Spare clothes everywhere, including in his bag. Keep it completely private from everyone else in the house, including the other children. Do not raise it with him again.

13. Oversight.

The two entries describing it as deliberate need correcting on the record, not quietly left. That is a supervision item, and so is the carer’s own growing difficulty with it.

14. Notifications.

The GP, the child’s social worker, and the school, with a specific ask of the school about privacy and spare clothes. This has been going on fourteen months without being notified as a health need, which is why no service has ever been attached to it.

15. Signatures.

Nobody has owned this as health rather than behaviour. Until a named person does, the reward charts will keep coming back.

What the analysis produced.

One medical appointment, and the removal of almost everything the household was doing. Most of what needs to happen here is stopping things.

Worked example: a fifteen-year-old who keeps leaving

The situation.

Keeley is fifteen and has gone missing overnight four times in six weeks. She comes back by herself, says nothing about where she has been, and has a second phone her carers were not told about. She has new trainers nobody bought her. Her carers have started taking her phone when she comes in.

1. Current circumstances.

The first time was the week her mother’s new baby was born. Since then it has been roughly fortnightly and the gaps are shortening. She has stopped going to her football club.

2. Repeated behaviours.

Four times, lengthening each time, and the pattern of the return is the same: she comes back between six and eight in the morning, is confronted at the door, and does not speak for the rest of the day.

3. Identity.

Fifteen, in care, and the only one of her friends who has to explain where she lives. The people she is going to have given her something she does not get anywhere else, which is somewhere she is wanted and does not have to explain anything.

4. Triangulation.

School has noticed nothing, which is itself worth asking about. Her mother has not been asked whether Keeley has been in touch. The police have returned her twice and no return interview has been shared with the household.

5. Interventions completed.

Taking the phone, a shorter curfew, and losing her allowance for a fortnight. All three were introduced after the second time, and the third and fourth times followed. The carers have also, between the second and third, twice stayed up and said nothing when she came in, and both of those were followed by her saying a little.

6. Compliance and capacity for change.

She is not unable to stay in. She is choosing to leave, and the question is therefore what leaving is getting her, and what staying is costing her.

7. Agency.

Her contact is set by somebody else, her placement by somebody else, her school by somebody else. Leaving is the one decision she makes entirely on her own, and it works every time.

8. Lived experience.

From inside: a new baby has arrived in her mother’s house and she is not in it. Somewhere else, people are pleased to see her. She has worked out that coming home produces a confrontation, so each return is worse than the one before.

9. Analysis.

Best explanation: she is running towards something rather than away, and the something is being wanted, which was in short supply the week her mother had a baby. Running alongside that, and the one that has to be assumed until excluded: she is being exploited. The second phone, the trainers, the lengthening absences and the silence are the ordinary indicators. These two explanations are not alternatives. The first is what makes the second possible.

10. Crisis indicators.

The gaps are shortening. There is a second phone. There are items nobody bought. She has dropped the one thing she was good at. Each of those alone would be worth raising. Together they are a pattern that needs acting on this week.

11. Thresholds.

Every absence goes through the missing child procedures, every time, without exception. Separately: the household threshold is not about whether they can tolerate it but about whether she can be kept safe here, and that is a question for the team around her rather than for the carers alone.

12. Interventions to implement.

Change the return. No confrontation at the door: food, warmth, bed, and the conversation the next day. That single change is the whole intervention, because it is the only thing that will get information. Stop taking the phone, which removes her route to her mother and tells her nothing. Get the police return interviews into the household. Ask for an exploitation assessment. Get her back to football, with the fees paid and the lifts arranged. And give her something real to decide in the meantime.

13. Oversight.

The two nights the carers said nothing and she talked a little are the most important thing in this file and are not recorded anywhere. Get them in. That is the evidence that the approach works.

14. Notifications.

Exploitation concerns, the second phone, the items, and the dropped activity. Formally, in writing, named as exploitation indicators rather than as behaviour. A fifteen-year-old going missing recorded as defiance does not get a service attached to it.

15. Signatures.

Who owns the exploitation question, and by when. If nobody is named, nobody is holding it, and she will go missing again before anybody notices that.

What the analysis produced.

One change in the household, which is how she is met at the door, and one escalation, which is the exploitation assessment. Everything the household had tried so far had made it worse, and that is recorded rather than hidden, because it is the finding.