Belonging, Confidence and Friendships
13.1 The main points
A child needs to belong somewhere, and belonging in your family does not mean losing their own. Children know whether they are a guest or a member of the household, and they work it out from small things. Praise often makes things worse for our children. Name the action, say it sideways, keep it short. Separate the child from the behaviour every single time. A child who believes nothing they do makes a difference needs real control over something small and real. One reliable adult is the strongest protection a child can have, and it is usually undramatic. If something is happening right now, look it up in Common Challenges: An A to Z.
13.2 Belonging
13.2.1 Why a child needs to belong somewhere
Every child needs to be part of something. Not looked after. Part of. A child who is well cared for but does not feel they belong anywhere is still carrying something heavy. They watch other people’s families and cannot place themselves in one. Belonging in your family does not mean losing their own. Children can belong in two places, and in ordinary life they do it all the time. Children in care are often made to feel they have to choose, usually by accident, and then they choose neither, because neither is safe.
13.2.2 Guest or family member
Children know which one they are, and they work it out from small things long before anybody says anything to them. Signals that say guest. Nothing of theirs on display. Food they are offered rather than food they take. Asking permission for things nobody else asks permission for. Being told rather than consulted. A room that could be packed up in an hour. Their name not on anything. Not being told family news. Being outside the joke. Somebody else’s belongings still in their room. Signals that say member. A photograph on the wall alongside everybody else’s. Their mug. A place at the table that is theirs. Their height marked on a door frame. Being in the family group chat. Being told that an aunt is ill. Being asked what the family should do at the weekend. Their drawings on the fridge for as long as anybody else’s. None of that costs anything, and all of it is noticed.
13.2.3 Christmas, holidays, birthdays and weddings
The big occasions are where it becomes obvious. Included means the same as everybody else. A stocking the same size. The same sort of present, and the same number of them. In the photographs, in the middle rather than at the edge. At the wedding as part of the family rather than as an extra. Accommodated means present but alongside. The child who comes too. The child who gets the practical gift while the others get the thing they wanted. The child who is not in the picture that goes on the wall. Nobody intends the second one, and children spot it immediately. Two practical things. Plan it well in advance, because these occasions cost money and need permissions, and asking in December is too late. And ask the child what they would like to do, because some children find family occasions unbearable and would rather something smaller. Being asked is itself part of belonging.
13.2.4 Belonging without pretending
A child who is not your child, and knows it, should not be told that they are. Do not pretend. Do not steer them towards mum and dad. Do not describe them as your own in front of them unless they have asked you to. Do not build a story they will have to take apart later. What works is being specific rather than warm and vague. “You live here and this is your home” is true. “You are part of this family” is true. “I’m not your mum, and I’m not trying to be, and you still belong here” is the sentence a lot of children need and very rarely hear. Let the child decide what to call you, and let them change it. Some use first names. Some use mum or dad. Some switch depending on who is listening, and some avoid calling you anything at all for years. All of that is fine, and none of it is a measure of how the placement is going.
13.2.5 Short placements
A child who is with you for a few weeks still needs to belong while they are there. Carers sometimes hold back, on the grounds that it would be unkind to let a child settle into something they are about to lose. That is the wrong way round. A child who spends three weeks being a guest learns that they are the kind of child who does not belong anywhere. A child who spends three weeks properly included learns that belonging is possible, and takes that away with them. So do all of it anyway. The mug, the photograph, the place at the table, their name on the door. It is not cruel to let a child settle. The leaving is hard either way. Then help them take something with them. Photographs. Things that are theirs. Something written down about their time here, which keeping the record for the child covers.
Critical Actions — 3. Identity
Family membership is an identity need, and it is the one most often assumed rather than assessed. A child can be well cared for and still not believe they are part of the family, and nobody finds out unless somebody asks.
13.3 Self-esteem
13.3.1 Being liked as you are
Most of our children have been valued for behaving. Be good, be quiet, be helpful, and you will be all right. The love is conditional, and they know exactly what the conditions are. Acceptance is different. It means the child is liked as they are, including on the bad days, and that nothing they do changes whether they are wanted. In practice that means your warmth does not move with their behaviour. You can be annoyed about what they did and still be pleased to see them. Most adults do not manage both at the same time, and a child who has only ever had the first is watching for the second. Say it out loud sometimes, in ordinary words. “I like having you here.” “I’m glad you’re mine to look after.” Not after a good week. On a Tuesday, for no reason.
13.3.2 Why praise often makes things worse
Carers are told to praise, so they do, and then something odd happens. The child gets worse. They destroy the thing they just made, say it is rubbish, or start an argument an hour later. The reason is that praise contradicts what the child believes about themselves. If you are certain you are bad, being told you are good is not pleasant. It is confusing and threatening, and the quickest way out of it is to prove that you were right all along. Some children also hear praise as pressure. If I did well today, I will be expected to do well tomorrow, and I cannot promise that. And some have had praise used against them. “After everything I’ve done for you” follows “you’re such a good girl” in a lot of childhoods. So the usual advice does not work, and carers who try it, watch it fail and then stop praising altogether have not got the answer either.
13.3.3 What works instead
Name the action, not the person. “You put your plate in the sink” rather than “you’re so good”. The first is a fact and cannot be argued with. The second is a claim about their character, and it will be. Say it sideways. While you are both doing something else, not facing them, and without a pause afterwards for their reaction. Keep it short and move on. One sentence, then carry on with what you were doing. A long appreciative speech is unbearable. Count the effort rather than the result. “You went in even though you didn’t want to.” Do not stack it up. Three compliments in a row will undo the first one. Do not use it to make a point. “See, you can do it when you try” is a criticism, and the criticism is the part the child hears. Do not do it in front of an audience, and particularly not in front of other children. Expect it to fail sometimes anyway, and do not stop. A child who cannot take it this year may be able to next year, and what changes in between is that it kept being offered.
13.3.4 Separating the child from the behaviour
Every time, without exception, however tired you are. “That was a horrible thing to say” rather than “you’re horrible”. “Hitting is not allowed here” rather than “you’re violent”. “This morning was hard” rather than “you’ve been a nightmare”. A child who is told what they are will believe it, and will then behave accordingly, because people act in line with who they think they are. This applies to what you say about them to other people within their hearing, and to what you write about them, which describing behaviour without labelling the child covers.
13.3.5 Helping a child survive their own mistakes
A child with low self-worth cannot afford to be wrong, because being wrong confirms everything. So they lie about small things, deny what you watched them do, blame somebody else, or fall apart over a spelling mistake. What helps is making mistakes ordinary in your house. Be wrong out loud yourself. Get something wrong, say so, fix it, carry on. Children learn far more from watching an adult be wrong than from being told that it is all right to be wrong. Do not require an admission. Getting a child to confess achieves nothing and makes the next time worse. Deal with the thing itself and let them keep their dignity. Keep your reaction small. If a spilt drink produces a sigh and a change of tone, the child has learned that mistakes carry a cost. Do not retell their mistakes later as funny stories. A child who hears their worst moment become an anecdote will not risk another one.
13.4 Feeling effective
13.4.1 Children who believe nothing they do makes any difference
Some children have learned that what they do has no bearing on what happens to them. They asked and nothing came. They behaved well and were moved anyway. They told somebody and nothing changed. A child who has learned that stops trying. It looks like laziness, or not caring about consequences. It is neither. It is a reasonable conclusion drawn from evidence. It is also one of the things that keeps a child stuck, because getting better requires believing that effort can change something.
13.4.2 Real choices in small places
The repair for it is control over real things, starting very small. Real means the answer is genuinely theirs and you will not override it. A choice you are prepared to undo is not a choice, and children test that straight away. So offer things you can live with either way. What is for tea on Thursday. Which wall the bed goes against. What goes on their walls. Whether the light stays on. Which jobs they do, rather than whether they do any. What the family does on Saturday, now and again. Then stick to it, including when they choose badly, within reason. A child who picks the boring option and has to live with it has learned something about cause and effect that no conversation will teach them.
13.4.3 Letting them do it slowly and badly
It is quicker to do it yourself and the result is better. Do it anyway. Let them make the toast, carry the plate, fill in the form, pack their own bag, make the phone call, pay at the till. Expect it to be slow, messy and wrong at first. Do not take over halfway through. Taking over says: I knew you couldn’t. If it has to be fixed, fix it later and out of sight. This matters for two different groups. Children who were looked after by somebody who did everything for them have no practice. Children who had to do everything for themselves have the practice but no belief that anybody will catch them.
13.4.4 Responsibility that builds rather than burdens
There is a line here and it is worth knowing where it sits. Responsibility that builds. A job that is theirs, that matters a little, that they can actually do, and that somebody notices. Feeding the cat. Locking up. Being in charge of the shopping list. Responsibility that burdens. Looking after younger children. Managing an adult’s feelings. Keeping a secret. Being the one who holds the household together. Many of our children arrive already carrying this and will reach for it again, because it is the role they know. If a child is quietly taking on the parent’s job in your house, take it off them gently and give them something smaller and real instead. Being praised for being so grown up and so helpful will keep a child in that role for years.
13.4.5 Why control battles are often about something else
A child who fights you over small things is usually not fighting about the thing. A child who refuses a coat, argues about bedtime by four minutes, insists on one particular cup, or will not move out of a doorway may have found the only thing in their life they get to decide. That reading changes what you do. The question is not how to win it. The question is where this child could be given something real to control, so that they do not have to take it from the edges. Give more away where you can, and hold the line where it matters. Children who have a reasonable amount of genuine control fight much less for the unreasonable kind.
Critical Actions — 7. Agency
Feeling effective is agency described from the child’s side. Look for where this child currently has real influence over something that matters to them, and if the answer is nowhere, that is the finding to act on.
13.5 Friendships and other children
13.5.1 Why friendships are hard for our children
A child who has not been able to trust adults has not learned the things that friendships need. Reading other people. Trusting that somebody who is cross with you will still be your friend tomorrow. Taking turns. Losing. Not needing to control the game. Coping with being left out. Saying sorry. All of that is learned at home, early, across thousands of small exchanges, and our children often did not get it. So the difficulty is not shyness and it is not being unlikeable. It is a missing set of skills, and like any missing skill it can be taught.
13.5.2 The specific things that go wrong
Controlling the game. A child who cannot bear not knowing what happens next will try to run everything, and other children drift away. Losing. Losing a game can be unbearable for a child whose sense of themselves is already fragile. Practise it at home, in games that do not matter, where losing happens to you as well and is survivable. Misreading people. A child who grew up watching adults for danger will read a neutral face as hostile and respond to an attack nobody made. Going too fast. Intense friendships, a best friend declared on day one, things given away, everything told. Then the collapse when it does not hold. Being teased. Very little margin before it becomes a crisis. You can work on all of these at home, and the guidance on play is where that happens. Games where somebody loses, where you take turns, and where things do not go to plan are friendship practice.
13.5.3 Parties, playdates and sleepovers
These are harder in fostering than they ought to be. Sleepovers may need checks. Other parents may be wary. Some children cannot manage a whole party. And an invitation often arrives on the day. Do it anyway, and work round it. Host rather than send. It is easier for the child, you can see what happens, and other parents find it easier to agree to. Start short. An hour, not an afternoon. End it before it goes wrong rather than after. Be around but not on top. A child who is struggling needs to be able to find you without having to explain why. Get the permissions in place in advance, so an invitation can be accepted on the day it arrives. And when it goes wrong, which sometimes it will, do not turn it into a lesson. Food, something familiar, and try again another week.
13.5.4 Friendships that worry you
Some friendships will concern you, and the older the child the more it matters. Banning rarely works and usually makes the friendship more attractive. It also means the child stops telling you about it, and then you cannot see anything at all. Stay close enough to know. Be the house the friends come to. Learn their names. Offer the lifts. Be pleasant to people you have doubts about. Say what you have noticed rather than what you have concluded. “I notice you come back from his house upset” is much harder to argue with than “he’s a bad influence”. Keep your relationship with the child above all of it. The relationship is what protects a teenager, which the guidance on twelve to eighteen covers. A child who can still talk to you is safer than a child who has been forbidden. And where there is real risk, say so to the child’s social worker, and bring what you have actually seen.
13.5.5 Clubs and activities
Something a child is good at, outside the house, with other children, is one of the most protective things in their life. Expect them to want to quit. Often within weeks, often just as they start to get somewhere, and often straight after being praised. Sabotage when things are going well is covered elsewhere in this guidance. So choose carefully and commit. Not five things at once. One thing, which they chose, with the kit and the lifts sorted out properly. Hold the line through the wanting to quit, gently, for a while. “Let’s go three more times and then decide.” Most children who are allowed to stop the moment it gets hard never find the thing they are good at. Then make it possible for it to last. Pay for the year. Get the permissions. Tell the club what they need to know and nothing beyond that. And go and watch.
13.6 Resilience
13.6.1 What resilience is, and what it is not
Resilience is not toughness, and it is not managing without help. A child who copes with everything on their own and never asks for anything is not resilient. They are alone. Resilience is being able to come through difficulty, and it is built as much from things outside the child as from anything inside them. At least one reliable relationship. A sense of being able to affect something. Something they are good at. And some reason to expect that the future might be all right. That matters practically, because it means resilience is something you build rather than something a child either has or lacks. You cannot make a child tougher. You can give them those four things.
13.6.2 One reliable adult
The strongest protection for a child who has had a bad start is one adult who is reliably there. Not a perfect adult. A consistent one. Usually that is you, and it will not feel like enough, because it is undramatic and it is mostly just turning up. What makes it work is being the same. The same response to the same thing. Being there at the time you said. Doing the small thing you promised. Being recognisably yourself on a bad day. It does not have to be only you, and it is worth making sure the child has more than one candidate. A grandparent in your family. A teacher. A coach. An independent visitor. Somebody whose interest in the child does not depend on the placement continuing. Build those relationships on purpose, and protect them if the child moves on.
13.6.3 Being good at something
Being competent at something is one of the few things that changes how a child sees themselves from the outside in. It does not matter what it is. Football, drawing, animals, cooking, fixing bikes, a game, an instrument, running. What matters is that it is theirs rather than something you are pleased about, and that it improves with practice, so the child gets to experience effort producing a result. Look for what they already move towards rather than what you would choose for them. Then resource it properly, and talk about it as part of who they are. A child described at home as the one who is good with animals has been handed something to be.
13.6.4 Hope, and picturing a future
A great many of our children cannot picture a future. Ask a fifteen-year-old in care what they will be doing at twenty-five and you may get nothing at all. That is not a lack of ambition. If everything so far has been decided by other people and most of it has gone badly, there is no reason to expect the future to be different, and imagining it is painful. So go gradually. Talk about next year before you talk about adult life. Point out the small evidence that effort works. Introduce them to people who have been where they are and are all right now. Keep the ordinary expectations of a childhood in place, because exams, driving lessons, a job and a holiday are what a future is made of. And be careful with promises about the future. A child who has been told more than once that things will be fine, by people who could not deliver it, will not believe you either. What they will believe is the thing you said you would do on Saturday, done on Saturday.