Supporting a Child Through Court Proceedings
10.1 The main points
During proceedings a child’s future is genuinely undecided, and most children know it even when nobody has told them. You cannot tell a child what will happen. You can tell them who decides, roughly when, and that you will tell them as soon as you know. Delay is normal, and to a child it reads as adults failing to decide about them again. Never reassure a child with something you cannot deliver. What you write during this period may be read by people it was not written for. Keep what you saw separate from what you concluded. Your own uncertainty shows. Name it briefly rather than hiding it. If something is happening right now, look it up in Common Challenges: An A to Z.
10.2 What proceedings are, from the child's side
10.2.1 What is happening
Care proceedings are the court process that decides where a child will live in the long term and who holds responsibility for them. While they are going on the child usually lives under a temporary order, which is why a placement during proceedings is not settled even when it looks settled. The court is expected to decide within about six months, although many cases take longer. The possible outcomes usually include going home, living with a relative, long-term fostering, or adoption. You do not need to understand the law. You do need to know, at any point, what the current plan is, what the alternative plan is, and when the next hearing is. Ask the child’s social worker, and ask again whenever something changes.
10.2.2 Why this period is different from the rest of a placement
In a settled placement a child’s uncertainty is mostly about themselves. During proceedings the uncertainty is official. Adults the child has never met are deciding where they will grow up, and the child can feel that happening without being told any of it. Several things follow. Children hold back. There is little point settling into somewhere you may be leaving, so a child may keep part of themselves out of your home. It can look like rejection and it is usually self-protection. Children test harder. If you are going to send me away, let us get it over with. Behaviour often gets worse around hearings without anyone connecting the two. Children overhear. Phone calls, car journeys, a word at a contact handover, something said in a playground. Assume a child knows more than they have been told, and that some of what they know is wrong. Children blame themselves. A child who believes the outcome depends on their behaviour will be either very good or very bad, and both come from the same belief.
10.2.3 Parallel planning, and living with two futures
Social workers often plan for two outcomes at the same time, so that whichever the court decides, something is ready. That is sensible. From the child’s side it means being told that one of two very different lives is coming, and that nobody knows which. Children manage this better when both futures are talked about in the same tone, rather than one being treated as the real plan and the other as a formality. A child who has only ever heard about going home, and then does not go home, has had no preparation at all. So talk about both without predicting either. “If you go home, that would mean this. If you stay here, that would mean this. Nobody knows yet which it will be.”
10.3 Holding a child through not knowing
10.3.1 What you can say, and what you cannot
You cannot tell a child what the court will decide. Do not guess, and do not reassure a child with something you cannot deliver. “You’ll be staying here, don’t worry” is the most damaging sentence on this page. What you can say, and should: Who decides. A judge, whose job is to decide what is best for the child after hearing from everybody. Who speaks for them. They have their own guardian and their own solicitor, whose job is the child’s interests and nobody else’s. When. The next hearing, in a form the child can hold. “After Easter” rather than a date eleven weeks away. That they will be told, by whom, and that you will not keep it from them. That it is not their fault and not their decision. Nothing they do will change the outcome. For most children that is a relief rather than a disappointment. “I don’t know” said steadily is better than false comfort. Children can live with not knowing. They cope far less well with being told something that turns out to be untrue.
10.3.2 When will I know?
Children ask this constantly, and you may be answering the same question for months. Answer it the same way every time. Repeating the same answer calmly is itself reassuring, because it shows the child that the ground has not moved. Give them something to measure time against. A calendar on the wall with the next hearing marked. Counting in half terms and holidays rather than weeks. A young child cannot hold “eleven weeks” at all. Do not avoid the subject because you have nothing new to say. A child who notices the adults going quiet decides that something bad is being kept from them.
10.3.3 Delay and hearings that move
Hearings get moved. Cases are adjourned. A date the child has been counting down to is suddenly not the date. To a child this is not a procedural delay. It is adults failing to decide about them again, and it confirms that what they are told cannot be relied on. Tell the child promptly when a date moves. Say that it happens often and that it is not about them. Give the new date if there is one, and say plainly if there is not. Expect the days after a moved hearing to be hard, and avoid making other demands of the child that week. Court dates become dates the child’s body remembers, which is covered in the guidance on triggers, anniversaries and re-traumatisation.
Critical Actions — 8. Lived experience
What the child believes is happening is not the same as what is happening, and during proceedings that gap is at its widest. Ask what they think the court is for and what they think will happen, and record the answer in their words. It is often the first time anyone has checked.
10.4 What the child sees happening around them
10.4.1 Assessments of their parents
The child’s parents are being assessed, and the child usually knows. They may be hopeful, they may defend their parents to you, they may be furious with them, and it can change within a day. Do not comment on how an assessment appears to be going, even when you have formed a view. Do not tell a child their parent is doing well, and do not hint at the opposite. If a child asks whether their mum is passing, say that you do not know, that people are helping her and looking at how things are going, and that the judge will decide. What not to say about birth family applies without exception during this period.
10.4.2 Contact changing because of the proceedings
Contact often changes during proceedings, sometimes a great deal, and the reason is usually legal rather than anything the child has done. An increase can unsettle a child as much as a reduction. More time with a parent raises hope, and it is still a change in the child’s week, so it often brings more unsettled behaviour rather than less. Tell the child before it changes if you possibly can, say why in the simplest honest words, and expect the effect in the hours afterwards rather than at the time. Contact, from the child’s side covers this in more detail.
10.4.3 Their guardian and their solicitor
A child in proceedings has a guardian, whose job is to work out what is best for them and tell the court, and a solicitor, who is the child’s own lawyer. Children often do not realise these people are on their side, rather than more adults making decisions about them. Say it plainly: this person’s whole job is you. Make the visits easy. Let the child choose where in the house. Be nearby but out of the room if that is what they want. Do not ask afterwards what they said. A child who thinks their answers come back to you will not give honest ones.
10.4.4 Being asked what they want, for the court
At some point the child will be asked what they want, and their answer goes to the court. This is the heaviest thing asked of a child during proceedings. In their own mind they may be choosing between the person they love and the person who looks after them, and they may believe they are deciding their parent’s future. So say out loud the things they will not work out for themselves. That saying what you want is not the same as choosing. That the decision belongs to the judge. That nobody will be angry with them whatever they say. Then stay out of it. Do not ask what they said, do not tell them what you hope they will say, and do not react if you find out. A child who can sense your preference will give you the answer they think you want. Being asked what you want covers how to ask a child things without putting them on the spot.
10.5 Your own part
10.5.1 Your records during proceedings
What you write during proceedings may be read by the court, by the child’s parents, by their solicitors, and later by the child. That does not change what your recording is for, and it should not make you cautious. It does make two things matter more. Keep what you saw separate from what you concluded. “Came home from contact, did not speak for two hours, ate no tea” is an observation. “Contact clearly upset him” is a conclusion. Both are useful, and they are not the same thing. Write it close to the event. Dates, times, and what was actually said. A record written the same evening carries weight that a memory three months later does not. How to write it is covered in Recording And The Child’s Record, and it applies here unchanged: write as though the child will read it, because they may.
10.5.2 Your own uncertainty
You are waiting too, and what you are waiting to hear is whether a child you may love is staying. That shows. A child reads your face and your body before your words, and a feeling you are managing privately is still in the room. Staying Calm covers what to do about it. So name it briefly, in the way that page describes, rather than behaving as though the house is normal. Take the rest of it to supervision. You should not be waiting for this news on your own.
10.5.3 If you are asked to give evidence
This is uncommon, and you will be supported through it if it happens. The process, who prepares you and what to expect are in the policies rather than here. What belongs here is the child. If you are going to court, think about what they will see: you being nervous, you being out for the day, something formal happening in the house. Tell them something simple and true about where you are going. Afterwards, whatever happened, the child needs the ordinary evening to still be the ordinary evening.
Critical Actions — 9. Analysis
Proceedings pull recording towards proving something. Keep observation and analysis in separate sentences, say what each one rests on, and say when you do not know. A record that keeps the two apart is more use to the court, and far more use to the child who reads it later.
10.6 The decision, and the days after
10.6.1 Being told
Find out in advance who is telling the child, when, and in what words. Ask to be told at the same time or before, so that you are not hearing it alongside them. A child should be told by someone who knows them, somewhere they feel safe, not in a corridor and not as an aside. If that is not what is planned, say so beforehand rather than afterwards. Then expect anything. Some children cry. Some ask if they can go and play. Some say nothing for days. A flat reaction does not mean the child is fine.
10.6.2 When it is not what the child wanted
A child told they are not going home has lost something, even when they are safe and even when they are staying with people they love. Do not put the positive beside it. “At least you’re staying with us” is true, and it is not what the child needs in that hour. Let it be a loss first. Expect grief, and expect it to come out as behaviour rather than as sadness. Expect it to come back on dates: the hearing, the day they were told, the first Christmas afterwards. Expect it to affect your relationship, sometimes badly. A child may be angry with you precisely because you are the person they are staying with. That is not a judgement on you.
10.6.3 When it is not what you wanted
A child going home, or to a relative, when you believe it is the wrong decision is one of the hardest things in fostering. Say what you think, properly and in the right places, before the decision. Afterwards, the child needs you to help them move towards the thing that is actually happening. A child who senses that you disapprove of their new home carries your doubt into it, which helps nobody. Arriving And Leaving covers how to help a child leave well, and Looking After Yourself covers what this does to carers. Keep saying what you think in supervision. Disagreeing with a decision does not stop being legitimate once the decision is made, and it belongs on the record.
Critical Actions — 15. Signatures
A decision has an owner. After the final hearing, check that the plan is written down, that it says who is responsible for what, and that you have a copy. The same question from the child’s side: did a named person explain the decision to them, and did anybody write down what they said back?