Identity, Birth Family and Contact

11.1 The main points

Identity is part of recovery, not an extra. A child who does not know who they are cannot settle. Get the everyday things right: food, hair and skin, language, prayer, the calendar. These are not details. Never criticise a child’s family, even mildly. You will lose the child rather than change their mind. Contact matters to a child even when it goes badly, and a child falling apart afterwards is not on its own a reason to stop it. A child may grieve a parent who hurt them, and that grief is real. What you notice before and after contact is often the most current evidence anybody has. If something is happening right now, look it up in Common Challenges: An A to Z.

11.2 Identity, culture and religion

11.2.1 Why this is part of recovery

A child who does not know who they are cannot settle, however kind the home. Identity is not an addition to therapeutic care and it is not a box on a form. It is one of the needs a child arrives with, alongside safety and comfort, and it goes unmet more often than the others because it is the one nobody notices is missing. A child who is warm, well fed and cared for, in a house where nothing about them is reflected back at them, is still losing something every day.

11.2.2 What a child loses when they come into care

Being removed from home removes much more than the home. Language. A child may stop hearing their own language, or stop being spoken to in it. Children lose a language within months. Food. The things that taste like family. The smell of a particular meal on a particular day of the week. The shape of the week. Prayer at certain times. Fasting. Festivals. Days that mean something. Community. A mosque, a church, a temple, a street, a shop where people knew them. People who look like them. For some children, coming into foster care is the first time they have lived among people of a different race, and often nobody says anything about it at all. Their name. How it is pronounced. A shortened version they never used at home. Being called something easier. None of this appears in a referral under losses. All of it is loss.

11.2.3 Getting the everyday things right

This is practical, and it is most of the job. Food. Ask what they ate at home, and ask their family if you can. Cook it, badly at first, and keep trying. Buy the brands they recognise. Keep dietary rules properly rather than approximately. A child who has been taught that something is forbidden, and who watches you treat it as flexible, learns that you do not take them seriously. Hair and skin. Learn what this child’s hair and skin need. If you do not know, say so and find somebody who does. Get the right products and enough of them. Do not cut a child’s hair to make it easier to manage. For a child whose hair has been neglected, having it properly cared for is one of the fastest ways to show them that you see them. Clothing. What is right for them, not what you would choose. Prayer and worship. Somewhere to pray, at the right times, without it being awkward. A way of getting to worship. Being taken, rather than merely allowed. The calendar. Know when the important dates fall, including the ones that move each year. Mark them properly rather than mentioning them. Language. Find a way for the child to keep hearing and speaking it: family, community, online, a class, another carer. Ask the child, and ask their family. Most of this is held by people you can simply ask, and the asking is itself part of it.

11.2.4 Shame, and children who refuse all of it

Some children want none of it. They will not eat the food, will not speak the language, do not want to go to worship, do not want to be seen as different in any way. This is usually not preference. It is shame, or a child trying hard to belong where they now live, or a child who associates their own culture with what happened to them. Do not force it, and do not let it drop. Keep it available without requiring it. Keep cooking the food and offering it. Keep going to the festival yourself. Keep the language in the house. A child who refuses at eight often comes back to it at fifteen, and what they come back to is whatever you kept alive in the meantime. Also check whether the refusal is about your house. A child who senses that their food is a nuisance, or their prayers inconvenient, will give them up in order to keep you.

11.2.5 Supporting a faith that is not yours

You do not have to share a child’s faith to support it, and not knowing anything about it is not a reason to do nothing. What is needed is practical. Find out what the child’s family and community actually do. Ask a local place of worship, and most will help gladly. Learn the basics, so that the child is not left teaching you everything. If your household has no faith, say so plainly and without apology, and make the arrangements anyway. If your household has a different faith, be careful. A child should not be brought along to your worship as the default, included in your prayers as though that were neutral, or left feeling that joining in would please you. Children work out very quickly what pleases a carer.

11.2.6 Race and racism

If you are white and the child is not, some of this is nobody else’s job but yours. Prepare them. The child will meet racism. A child who has never discussed it is left to work out on their own what has just happened to them. Talk about it before it happens, at a level that suits their age, so that the first conversation is not in the aftermath of something. Respond when it happens. Believe them immediately. Do not look for another explanation, do not suggest it was a misunderstanding, and do not tell them to ignore it. Then act: the school, the club, the person’s manager, in writing. Then tell the child what you did. Do not make the child manage your feelings about it. A carer who becomes very upset, or defensive, or who needs reassurance that they are not part of the problem, has handed the whole thing back to the child. Build in what your household cannot provide. People who share the child’s heritage, in the child’s actual life rather than in principle. Barbers and hairdressers, clubs, friends, mentors, community events. Expect to get things wrong. Ask, apologise briefly, change it, carry on.

11.2.7 Children who have arrived in this country alone

A child who has come here without their family carries everything above and more. They may share no language with you at first. Arrange interpreting properly rather than relying on a phone, certainly for anything that matters. They may have been through things on the journey that are worse than what they left. Do not ask. Let them tell you if and when they choose to. Their age may be disputed, and they may be treated as older than they say they are. That is painful in a way that is easy to underestimate, and the child in your house may be considerably younger than their paperwork says. They are likely to be carrying worry about people still at home, and that worry will occupy more of their mind than anything happening in your house. Food, prayer and language matter more here rather than less, because they may be the only familiar things left.

11.2.8 Getting it wrong

You will get things wrong. You will mispronounce a name for a month, buy the wrong thing, miss a date, ruin the food. Ask rather than guess. Apologise once, briefly, and fix it. Do not make a performance of the apology, because then the child has to manage your embarrassment as well. The mistakes are not what does the damage. What does the damage is a carer who decides the whole subject is too difficult or too sensitive to ask about, and quietly does nothing.

Critical Actions — 3. Identity.

Identity is a need to assess, not a courtesy to observe. Ask it as an assessment question: what does this child need in order to know who they are, and which of those needs is going unmet in this home right now?

11.3 Birth family

11.3.1 Why a child defends the people who hurt them

A child will often defend, idealise and long for the people who harmed them. Carers find this one of the hardest things to make sense of. There are several reasons, and all of them are worth knowing. They love them. That does not stop because of what happened. It is where they come from. Rejecting your family means rejecting part of yourself. Blaming the parent is unbearable. It is easier for a child to believe that they themselves were the problem than to believe that the adult who was supposed to love them did not manage it. They feel they have to stay loyal. A child may feel that being happy in your house is a betrayal. Settling in, enjoying it, calling it home, can all feel like going over to the other side. This last one is sometimes called a loyalty bind: a child caught between two sets of people, where getting close to one feels like betraying the other. Children in that position often manage it by keeping both at a distance, or by behaving badly with you in order to prove they have not changed sides.

11.3.2 Why criticising them loses you the child

Even mild criticism counts. A sigh. A raised eyebrow at a handover. “Well, she’s late again.” Any comparison between your house and theirs. The child hears it as a statement about themselves, because that parent is part of who they are. They will also defend the parent, out loud or silently, which means you have just made yourself the child’s opponent in an argument you did not intend to start. And they will stop telling you things. A child who thinks their family will be judged protects them by keeping you out, including out of things you need to know. So: what happened, without a verdict on the people. What not to say about birth family, in Life Story Work, gives the wording. The only thing to add here is that it holds at handovers, in the car, on the phone, and when you are sure the child cannot hear you.

11.3.3 Holding your own feelings

You will sometimes be looking after a child who was badly hurt by someone you then have to be civil to. You may be angry. You may find them hard to be around. You may think a decision about them is wrong. All of that is legitimate, and none of it goes anywhere near the child. It goes to supervision, and it needs to go there before it starts to show. A feeling you are managing privately is still in the room, which is covered in Staying Calm. One fact helps. Whatever was done, this is the person the child comes from and always will come from. Being able to be decent to them in front of the child is part of the job, and for some carers it is the hardest part of it.

11.3.4 Children who idealise, and children who say nothing

Some children talk about a parent constantly and perfectly. She is wonderful, she is coming to get them, she has a house ready. Do not correct it and do not agree with it. “You really miss her” is the safe answer, and it is also the true one. Some children never mention their family at all. That is not indifference and it is not something to push at. Leave the door open by mentioning them neutrally now and again, and let the child decide. Either of these can switch within a day. A child who has defended a parent for months may suddenly be furious with them and then defend them again the following week. Do not use the angry version against the parent afterwards, and do not treat it as the child finally seeing the truth.

11.3.5 Brothers and sisters placed elsewhere

Siblings placed somewhere else are often the relationship a child grieves most, and it usually gets less attention than contact with parents. Push for it. Ask what sibling contact is planned, ask why if there is none, and ask for it to be in the care plan. Then help it happen in practice: the driving, the hosting, the phone calls, the birthdays. A child may also have family they have never met or barely remember: a father, a grandparent, cousins, half-brothers and sisters they did not know existed. Finding out about them can matter enormously, and it belongs with their social worker and with their life story work rather than with you alone. Tell the social worker what the child has asked about.

11.4 Contact, from the child's side

11.4.1 Why it matters even when it goes badly

Contact is often difficult, sometimes upsetting, and occasionally looks as though it does nothing but harm. It still matters. It tells a child that their family exists and has not disappeared. It keeps a real person in the place where a fantasy would otherwise grow. And it tells the child that they are allowed to love them. A child with no contact and no explanation builds their own version of events, and that version is nearly always either much worse or much better than the truth, and it is nearly always about them.

11.4.2 Preparing a child beforehand

Tell them in advance. How far in advance depends on the child, and some children cannot hold a date for a week without it taking over everything. Say what is actually arranged. Who, where, how long, who else will be there, who is taking them. Children worry about the practical details. Do not promise anything you do not control. Not that their mum will be there. Not that she will bring the thing she said she would. Not that it will go well. If something is uncertain, say that it is uncertain. “It should be Saturday. If anything changes I’ll tell you as soon as I know.”

11.4.3 The build-up

The days before often show more than the day itself. Sleep goes. Appetite changes. Behaviour gets worse. A child may become clingy, or picky, or very controlling about small things. Some children insist they are not thinking about it at all while clearly thinking about nothing else. Lower the demands during that period, as far as you reasonably can. It is not a good week for a difficult conversation or a new expectation.

11.4.4 Afterwards

The hours after contact are usually the hardest part, and the behaviour is often at its worst. Carers sometimes conclude from this that contact is damaging the child. Sometimes it is. More often what you are looking at is a child who has had their whole history put back in front of them and has nowhere to put the feeling. Expect them to be unsettled and hard to reach, and do not treat that on its own as a verdict on contact. Expect it to come out as something unrelated: a row about a screen, a refusal to eat, something thrown. What helps is nothing planned for the rest of the day, food, a bath, a familiar film, low expectations, and you nearby without asking questions. Do not ask how it went as they come through the door. Let them tell you, or not.

11.4.5 What the behaviour around contact is telling you

Read it as information rather than as a problem. A child who falls apart afterwards every single time is telling you something. A child who is entirely fine afterwards every time is also telling you something. A child who is worse before than after is telling you something different again. Write down what you see with the dates, keep what you saw separate from what you concluded, and bring it to supervision. The decisions about contact are not yours to make, and the observations they should rest on are often only available to you.

11.4.6 When the parent does not come

This is one of the worst things that happens to a child in care, and it happens often. Tell the child as soon as you know. Do not dress it up, and do not make excuses on the parent’s behalf that may turn out not to be true. Do not fill the gap with a treat straight away. A child who is let down and immediately taken to the cinema learns that the feeling is not allowed to exist. Let it be disappointing first. Say the thing they will not say. “That is not your fault.” Say it even if they have not suggested that it was. Expect the following days to be harder than the day itself.

11.4.7 Contact the child arranges themselves

Children find their families. Through social media, through gaming, through a friend’s phone, through a relative who passes on a number. In the child’s own mind they are usually not doing anything wrong. They are doing what any child would do, which is trying to reach their own family. If you find out, tell the child’s social worker, because there may be reasons the child does not know about. Tell the child that you are doing it and why. Do not take the phone away and then question them. And do not take it as a betrayal of you. It is not about you at all.

11.4.8 Handing a child over

Taking a child to contact and handing them to someone you may have strong feelings about is hard, and it does not get much easier. Be ordinary about it. Say hello. Be pleasant. Keep it brief. A child watches a handover very closely, and a pleasant handover tells them that both halves of their life are allowed to exist in the same place. Afterwards, in the car on your own, is where you get to feel whatever you feel.

Critical Actions — 1. Current circumstances.

The week around contact is its own set of circumstances. A child who is dysregulated on a Wednesday every fortnight is not an unpredictable child.

11.5 When contact changes or stops

11.5.1 What each change means to a child

Contact gets reduced, supervised, moved somewhere else, changed to a phone or video call, or ended. Each of those means something specific to the child, and what it means is rarely what the paperwork says. Reduced usually reads as they want me less, or I did something wrong. Supervised reads as they think my mum is dangerous, which is a very hard thing for a child to hold about somebody they love. Moved takes away the one familiar thing in the arrangement. Changed to a phone call reads as a downgrade, however sensible the reason. Ended reads as a bereavement, and is best treated as one. Say which one is happening, in plain words, rather than letting the child work it out from what stops happening.

11.5.2 Grief for a parent who hurt them

A child can grieve a parent who hurt them badly, and that grief is real, large, and not confused. Carers sometimes expect relief and are taken aback by the depth of the sadness. Some children grieve harder for a parent who harmed them than they would for one who did not, because what they are grieving includes everything they never had. Do not look for the positive in it. Do not say it is for the best, that they are better off, or that they will understand when they are older. Those things may be true and none of them helps. Treat it as a death in the family, because to the child it often is. Expect anniversaries. Expect it to come back years later, and at ages when nobody is expecting it.

11.5.3 Supporting a child through a decision they did not make

The child did not choose this and may not accept it. They may be furious with the people who decided, which can include you because you are the one who is there. Be clear that the decision was not yours, without becoming the person who explains the reasoning behind it. You can say that it was decided by their social worker, or by the court, that you did not make it, and that you cannot change it. If the child wants to know why, the person who made the decision should be the one to explain it. Ask for that to happen, and ask for it to happen properly rather than in a sentence at the end of a visit. Do not take sides. Do not tell the child you disagree with it, even when you do, and do not tell them you agree with it either. “I know you didn’t want this” is enough, and it is honest.

11.5.4 What you notice is the evidence

Decisions about contact should rest on what the child is actually showing, and you are the only person who sees most of it. Record the before and the after every time. Dates, sleep, appetite, behaviour, what the child said, how long it took them to settle. Keep it factual. Bring it to supervision and bring it to reviews, including when it does not support the direction things are heading in. A child who has settled better since contact reduced is evidence. So is a child who has got worse. If you think a decision is wrong, say so properly and keep saying it. Speaking up for a child covers how. Disagreeing on the record is part of the job, not a complaint about it.

Critical Actions — 6. Compliance and capacity for change.

Contact decisions turn on this distinction. A parent can attend every session and change nothing, and the child usually knows which it is long before the paperwork does. Your before-and-after observations are often the most current evidence anyone holds.